Forked Thread: 1E DMG vs. 3E DMG vs. 4E DMG: 1e DMG in newer edions

[thedungeondelver]

I would suggest that these two things:

Forked from: 1E DMG vs. 3E DMG vs. 4E DMG



I keep hearing that the 1e DMG is so great,

about things most players don't care about.

are at odds with one another.

You keep hearing it's so great because, obviously, the 2nd statement is wrong.

 

[FireLance]

You keep hearing it's so great because, obviously, the 2nd statement is wrong.

That's your opinion, and it isn't obvious that your opinion is correct.

I liked the 1e DMG because of the cartoons. I generally found the tables to be good for adding flavor, but it is the kind of flavor that tends to be ignored by the players unless the DM works to make it important.