Agreed for sure, the format is without a doubt better for actual communication and sharing of ideas. I just think that the 'geek culture' or 'nerd community' or whatever term we wish to apply is now too fractured, too angry, and too tribal, to avoid seeing the same conversations go down the same paths, over and over and over.
We see it here every day. From questions of game design, edition, whatever. Its the same path, with the same people, making the same arguments.
They would be better served, to go find a discord that shares the same view, but then they lose the opportunity to grind that axe.