Wraithdrit
First Post
Hmmm... fuzzy math to follow:
What is better two hits at +5 or one at +7?
Do they do the same damage? Lets assume so (say a d8 for this example). If the skeleton is attacking with +7 to hit and needs a 21 then it needs a 14+ on the die. About a 28% chance of hitting (I'm assuming a 15+ would be 25%, and 11+ would be 50% so each of the five points in between is worth 3%). So, at of ten attacks, we could say on average 3 hits, for somewhere in the range of 7.5 pts of damage per hit (you said he had +3 strength, and I'm assuming 4.5 average damage on a d8). So thats 22.5 or 23 points of damage. Roughly.
If the same attacker against the same defender used the double weapon at +5/+5 then we are looking at a 16+ needed to hit, or roughly 22%. 2 out of ten. Or 4 out of 20 (the amount of attacks given for ten rounds) for a total of 29 points of damage.
So that would seem to say that going twin weapon would be good, but you are spending multiple feats on it. Feats that could be spent to up resistances (Lightning Reflexes), or Hit Points (Toughness on a skeleton... heh), or even something fun dodge or some such. Well... enough of this...
- Wraith
What is better two hits at +5 or one at +7?
Do they do the same damage? Lets assume so (say a d8 for this example). If the skeleton is attacking with +7 to hit and needs a 21 then it needs a 14+ on the die. About a 28% chance of hitting (I'm assuming a 15+ would be 25%, and 11+ would be 50% so each of the five points in between is worth 3%). So, at of ten attacks, we could say on average 3 hits, for somewhere in the range of 7.5 pts of damage per hit (you said he had +3 strength, and I'm assuming 4.5 average damage on a d8). So thats 22.5 or 23 points of damage. Roughly.
If the same attacker against the same defender used the double weapon at +5/+5 then we are looking at a 16+ needed to hit, or roughly 22%. 2 out of ten. Or 4 out of 20 (the amount of attacks given for ten rounds) for a total of 29 points of damage.
So that would seem to say that going twin weapon would be good, but you are spending multiple feats on it. Feats that could be spent to up resistances (Lightning Reflexes), or Hit Points (Toughness on a skeleton... heh), or even something fun dodge or some such. Well... enough of this...

- Wraith