Blood Jester said:
The Mallorean was a disappointment for me, but not totally awful. I thought he did much better with The Elenium, Sparhawk is an interesting character, and the series is a little darker than the others ('darker' being a very relative term).
Dark! Yeah, that's the criterion I use when choosing books for my kids...
Of the ones mentioned here (a couple new ones added), the order (more or less) in which I read them:
The Phantom Tollbooth (age 7--I get free reign at a school library)
Peter Pan
Mrs. Frisbee and the Rats of Nimh
Prydain Chronicles
Various Oz books
The Secret Garden
The Turn of the Screw
Mary Poppins, 2nd book also (Mary Poppins returns?)
a couple books of random fairy tales
Dark is Rising
anything I could find with Robin Hood
Wrinkle in Time series
La Morte d'Arthur (very heavy, I think I skipped Lancelot's book)
Once and Future King
The Hobbit.
The Chronicles of Narnia.
Lord of the Rings
tons of stuff that I can't remember any more.
That was by the time I was 10, so I'd already been playing D&D for a couple years. The three that made the biggest impact on me were The Phantom Tollbooth, Mrs. Frisbee and the Rats of Nimh and the Prydain Chronicles. After that I read everything in the school library and then the public library that involved fantasy settings at all. The librarians had to special order stuff, and it seemed by the time I was 10 that there was nothing else that they could dig up for me. (They recommended against La Morte, and afterward I agreed, so they gave me Once and Future King.)
I would probably add in the Belgariad now, but really only if I were reading with them. I'd definitely add Harry Potter.