guys and girls

Have you ever played a character not your gender

  • Yes, I'm a guy and I've played girl characters

    Votes: 347 68.8%
  • Yes, I'm a girl and I've played guy characters

    Votes: 22 4.4%
  • No, I'm a guy and I've only ever played guy characters

    Votes: 127 25.2%
  • No, I'm a girl and I've only ever played girl characters

    Votes: 8 1.6%

I'm male, and I've played female characters.

It seems, however, that I've coincidentally played mostly male characters in long-running games, because (apart from one-shots) I happen to have chosen to play female characters in games that just never lasted very long.

Many of the people I play with regularly have played cross-gender characters. Some of the people in my university gaming group could be pigeonholed as the stereotypical "social reject playing hot chicks to get off" if you were as uncharitably inclined as I am; others tend to play female characters often for some less-obvious psychological reason; others do it simply for the different experience.

For example, one of my close friends and regular gaming buddies played a female samurai in a Legend of the Five Rings freeform last year because the character he wanted to play was a particular kind of Japanese fantasy archetype which cried out in his mind for being female - he played the devoted bodyguard of an Imperial Magistrate with the requisite tragic romantic interest in her master.

The same player subsequently chose to play a female character in another freeform (this time, a Fading Suns one-shot) because he wanted to experiment with roleplaying a love story from a woman's perspective. Taken with the last paragraph, that sounds odd, but in the Legend of the Five Rings game it was much more of a "motivation", especially after her master disappeared, while in the Fading Suns game her romantic interest in another PC was much more of an active goal.

In the long-running Third Edition Planescape game I played in, a male player had a female PC - the only one to cross that gender line out of eight players, two of whom were women. This same player now runs a d20 Wheel of Time campaign in which the male DM of the Planescape game plays a female PC, natch.

Generally speaking, romance is not a big part of our games (though I'm aware that the first player I mentioned above tends to privately add in a great many themes in his own headspace to enhance the experience for himself, and I would not be surprised if romance was among them). Characters' gender doesn't usually matter, which I suspect reflects both the straightforward tone of quite a few games I've played and the egalitarian assumptions of D&D - if the rules reflected some kind of real difference between the sexes (which I think would be stupid, but go with me here), then people might choose to play cross-gender for mechanical reasons, in the same way that they choose to play nonhuman races for mechanical reasons.

Yet another friend of mine played a female PC in one of the most straightforward adventure-oriented D&D campaigns I've ever been part of, and the character's gender didn't come up at all.

On another related subject, the only time I've ever played a queer character was not because I had a yearning to try it out, but just as a not-so-subtle way of telling another player that I wasn't going to pay any attention to her incessant yammering about how pretty her character was, and how she was so good-looking male characters pretty much had to do what she told them to do, et cetera.

Admittedly, she had some basis for the latter claim, since this was Spycraft and being a knockout can be mechanically reflected in that system, but I had no patience for it.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I'm a guy, and I have a female ranger who is married to the party leader. She is about to give birth to their first child. A have another female character who is the daughter of the same ranger from a previous relationship. My wife plays mostly female characters, but she also has a big male macho Paladin who she has a great time with.
 

I'm a guy and I've never felt any desire to play a female character. One of my current players is a guy and never plays anything but female characters and it doesn't matter whether it is playing Evercrack or my Midnight campaign. I don't treat the characters any differently in the usual mode of play though it'll get REAL ugly for his female character the first time the party is captured by Orcs (Midnight Orcs are nastier than traditional D&D Orcs). I'm not some kind of sicko... just a realistic DM. Of course his character may actually live past that encounter... Orcs would probably just slay the other party members and throw them in a cook pot (especially the Dwarf) as soon as they were captured.
 

Queen_Dopplepopolis said:
My DM won't let us play characters that are not our gender. He says it makes things weird because it's hard to role play from a perspective that you, by nature, cannot understand...
That's a rather common stance. It's however pretty weird (or inconsequent), if you allow non-human races then (which can be far more different to humans, than males are to females and the other way around). :)

Bye
Thanee
 

Silver Moon said:
My wife plays mostly female characters, but she also has a big male macho Paladin who she has a great time with.
Heh. Another form of the larger then life approach. Cross-gender characters can easily get pretty extreme in their stereotypical behaviour, I suppose.

That's probably also why often (well, actually not that often, if you have mature players) females played by males are rather... uhm, well... you know what I mean. :p

This behaviour is probably also the reason why some DMs disallow cross-gender PCs.

It just seems natural, exploring the borders and going for the extremes.

Bye
Thanee
 
Last edited:


I'm female, and in two and a half years of gaming haven't yet played a male character, which isn't to say I never will - I just haven't run out of cool women to play yet! :cool:

I've seen cross-gendered PCs played both very compentently and very incompetently, so I wouldn't necessarily say it's not possible to play the opposite gender well. :)
 

Well lets see now?

I've played male characters and i have had guys in the group play female characters :cool: . There has been no severe stereotyping :heh: ...i use the term lightly...as we seem to manage to play the characters personality fairly well :p The only problems seem to arise when the characters class has been an Amazon :] ;) (it could just be the way i'm playing her :lol: ).

My fav male character was a staunchy dwarf fellow...quite dead...but for his short holy and heroic life, immensely fun..(i'll get my revenge someday you evil black dragon...he has cousins :D
 

I play cross-gender (female) characters fairly frequently.

For the most part, the arguments against it don't do much for me, for the reasons people have already mentioned. The only counter-argument I've ever heard that made any sense, given that people are allowed to play other species, was one of comparison: there are no real elves or trolls to compare against, so errors in roleplay are not as jarring. On the other hand, cross-gender or cross-cultural play gets contrasted against people's beliefs (stereotypes) about what those groups are "really" like.

. . . . . . . -- Eric
 

Pyske said:
I play cross-gender (female) characters fairly frequently.

For the most part, the arguments against it don't do much for me, for the reasons people have already mentioned. The only counter-argument I've ever heard that made any sense, given that people are allowed to play other species, was one of comparison: there are no real elves or trolls to compare against, so errors in roleplay are not as jarring. On the other hand, cross-gender or cross-cultural play gets contrasted against people's beliefs (stereotypes) about what those groups are "really" like.

. . . . . . . -- Eric

I can answer that argument: Given the cultural differences between the USA and western Europe, or even between the different countries in Europe alone, let alone between the West and the East, the Far East, the Orient or Africa, and then the differences between individual humans of the same culture, I can't take anyone seriously who wants to tell me that the differences between men and women are that great you can't roleplay a different gender. Consider also that adventurers are not exactly normal people, and more likely to be misfits and odd ones anyway.

Sorry folks, but stop trying to pretend you can tell me how a woman or man of a fantasy culture acts any better than you can tell me how an elf or dwarf acts.

And who said there was a "correct" way to roleplay a woman, or man anyway? Let me tell you this: Odds are that stereotype you may consider way off and stupid fits a real living human being somewhere out there.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top