• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Harry Potter IV - Spoilers welcome!

I have the day off today (for other reasons) and my wife and I have tickets for later this afternoon! W00t!

Anyone else seen this yet? How does it compare to 1) the book, 2) the previous movies?
 

log in or register to remove this ad



I saw the midnight showing last night.

The movie was great. Visual effects were superb, including the dragon, merfolk, Voldemort's face, and the Priori Incantatum, which was almost as cool as the Expecto Patronum effect from PoA. The acting keeps getting better. Fleur Delacour was sufficiently... distracting... for her role :). Don't look at me like that... the actress turns twenty-three in less than two weeks time. Cho was decent, but didn't get much screen-time.

Don't go in expecting to have the entire book layed out before you, though. There was a LOT cut from the books. The Dursleys never made an appearance, nor did Mrs. Weasley (unless I just missed her), and the movie starts the morning that they all go to the Quiddich World Cup. The Quiddich match itself is not shown; it jumps straight from the "Let the games begin" scene to the post-game celebrations. This of course cuts the Lepruchan Gold sub-plot, and the Harry-is-rich/Ron-is-poor arc, though the strife that is supposed to be in this book/movie between the characters is still handled adequately.

The trials were nicely done. The dragon was amazing, it moved well, was very believable. The merfolk trial was cool, too, and the hedge maze was extremely spooky. In one scene, the maze tries to close its walls to crush Harry - the entire theatre, myself included, let out a scream.

The gags in the movie were great. Fredngeorge's "advanced physical maturism" was funny, Ron and Harry trying to find dates for the ball had us all rolling in the aisles for several minutes ("Why do they always have to travel in packs?!"). My second-favorite funny moment was when Harry opened the Egg inside the prefect's bathroom... and Moaning Myrtle made an appearance. She kept coming closer... and closer... and closer... to our inadequately-clothed main character, who tried to keep his modesty by constantly piling bubbles around him. Top honors, though, go Malfoy's brief excursion as a ferret and Mrs. McGonagall's admonishment to Moody that "Transfiguration is never used as a punishment! Surely Dumbledore informed you of that!" and Moody's reply of "Well, he may have mentioned it."

Mad-Eye Moody... He didn't look anything like the pictures in the book, but I felt that the actor did very well in capturing his mood. He was a little more on the "insane" side of things than the "gravelly-voice creepiness" that I imagined in the books. His evertwirling eye was nice. The demonstration of the three unforgivable curses came out very good. Imperius on an enlarged spider-thingy, making it jump around on people (including poor Ron), had us all laughing. "Watch it, I can make it dance... I can make it jump. Perhaps onto Malfoy? Or maybe jump out the window," as it hit a lens in the classroom. The theatre seemed to realize that this wasn't quite funny, and silence came down when Moody continued with "Or maybe make her... drown herself" as he comes close to making the bug submerge itself in a bucket of water. Crucio had us all cringing, and Avada Kedavra garnered gasps and "NO!"'s from the audience.

Speaking of the killing curse, that brings us to the Graveyard. Voldemort, still in his pseudo-infant stage, is being carried by Wormtail, and instructs his servant to "Kill the spare." Immediately, Wormtail launces an avada kedavra curse upon Cedric, and he dies. Just dies. There's no theatrics, no suspenseful pause while we all wait for What-We-Know-Is-Coming(TM). It's as quick as a gunshot, and completely without emotion from the murderer. So sudden, so final, so cold. They handled this scene perfectly. I teared up when they finally got back to Hogwarts, and Amos Diggory cried over the body of his son. It was quite emotional.

You know how the scene for the next three movies is going to be set, when at the end Hermione asks Harry "Nothing's going to be the same, is it?"

He puts his hand on her shoulder, and says "No."

Voldemort is back.
 

Just got back from the noon show (I had one day of vacation left this year :)). Loved it. Way darker than the other films, but with some very decent laughs. For once, I felt that the changes that were made and things that were cut didn't detract from the film (with one exception that I'll get to in a bit), and in the case of SPEW, weren't missed at all. The Yule Ball was done very well, and wasn't as much of a break in the action as it was in the book. I'd read beforehand that the director had promised a much more "English" film, and it definitely came off that way. Sorta hard to describe.

The only part of the book that I felt was really missing from this film was the final fate of Barty Crouch Jr. In the book, it set up the entire conflict between the Ministry and Dumbledore and those loyal to him, and how nobody believes Harry. I really felt this would have been a critical scene going into the next film, and it seemed to be cut for the sake of ending on an up note.

I'd give it three and a half thumbs up, probably four if you don't know the book.

NOTE: fans of the band Pulp, look for Jarvis Cocker as the singer in the band that plays at the dance. Those were some decent songs they were doing too. Might have to look for that soundtrack.
 


I saw it today and I liked it better than the last one. I agree with feedback here. I liked that they focused most of the plot on Nevell as well cause of what will happen to him later on in the books. Ginny did not get to say much in the film but oh well. Im glad they showed more of Fred and George but was disappointmentt that Percy was cut and he has an important role in the next film I think. Overall, to me, the editing and storytelling was better than Azkaban.
 

Got back a few hours ago myself, and I'll join the apparent chorus that this is the best HP movie yet. I enjoyed it tons, and I thought that most of the cuts were carefully and skillfully done so as to leave the plot and feel of the book still pretty well intact.

My wife, who's never read the book, doesn't agree with me though. She said she never got the impression that they were actually in school, as there were practically no classroom scenes and that the Triwizard challenges seemed to just follow each other more or less immediately, rather than having been spaced out throughout the school year. She also thought that ironically, the movie was a lot of action, but very little magic.

I'm still mulling over her comments. It's not unexpected that we'd react to it differently; to me it was an adaptation of a book that I already knew very well, while to her it was the sequel to three movies that we own.
 

I will dissent. :)

Just got back and I enjoyed it, but it's not the best HP movie.

And my daughter, the resident HP nut who never finds fault with anything HP ranked it last of the four films. She plans to re-read the book tonight so she can go rip the movie to shreds on muggle.net this weekend.

My son, too, noticed the lack of magic in the movie (and he didn't like it). That didn't bother me, at all. There were enough magic curses flying around for me.

I liked the portrayal of Dumbledore in this film. He seems not quite 100% confident and actually a littler nervous that he doesn't have all of the information. I liked that.

The scene with Snape beating Ron and Harry was very funny. And George & Fred stole every scene they were in (when they had dialogue). The comic relief seemed more natural & less forced than in the three previous films.

Overall, I enjoyed it and I think they made some good cuts (that book really needed an editor). My test of a film is: Do I want to see it again? This one is a resounding "probably" for me. By contrast, the first two I only bought on DVD since my daughter liked them. The third one I loved and wanted to see again and buy right away. This film is good, but it's no PoA.
 

Oh, yeah, I loved the dragon (someone producing the next D&D movie, please see this one first) and the merfolk were great. No trace of some Disney "Little Mermaid" here!

Best special effects of the series so far.

Also saw the King Kong and Superman trailers (among others), so that was fun.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top