Harry Potter PoA: Hermione's punch?

[Mark]

Hey, maybe I'm going crazy, but does anyone else think that the way Hermione punched Malfoy in Prisoner of Azkaban would have landed her with a broken hand?

Maybe it did break but she used that bone growing stuff that they used on Harry in the other film but it had to be cut from the movie because of time constraints and how would it matter anyway since she has magical spells and could prolly use it to heal herself if she really wanted to and who cares if she did or didn't cause she's cool and a good role model for young girls in these dangerous and scary times when so many things that we see in the movies and on teevee is really bad and really scary and how come Ron didn't hit him first since Ron is really in love with her and all and if he would just stop being such a wimp which I guess is tough to do when his name is Wealey and he is always playing second fiddle to Harry but I think that the scene where they accidently hold hands might be a little too explicit for children under five so they might want to clean it up for the next couple a dozen films just to be sure they don't offend the censors who I hate anyway cause they always ruin my fun by cutting stuff out of perfectly good movies and what was I saying...?

 

[Enchantress]

Uhhh.......Yeah.

 

[reutbing0]

Maybe it did break but .....snip...... I saying...?

Mark...you're a genius. (On the downside, now there's coffee all over my laptop..*grumbles* )

 

[Mark]

Mark...you're a genius. (On the downside, now there's coffee all over my laptop..*grumbles* )

My apologies to your keyboard...

 

[Someone]

Well, the hits from the whomping (sp?) willow should have shattered Hermione´s ribs and most of the internal organs, too. Its magic!

 

[Enchantress]

Poor Ron, he seems to be the only one who's ending up in the hospital wing.

 

[Wolfspirit]

Heh, I actually looked at a high res trailer of the movie with that scene in it, and I still think the punch looked weird. Well, that and that it's pretty obvious that she was nowhere near hitting him

I could go into some discussion on my take on punching and various forms of self defense, but that would take too long

 

[Enchantress]

You have to admit, Malfoy certainly has a face that many people would want to hit.

 

[jasper]

Yes the poor kid playing Malfoy has hit the UGLY stage of being a teenager. What was nice was see some of younger kids from 2 who have out grown Harry.

 

[Enchantress]

I didn't recognize Neville at first because he had suddenly lost all of his baby fat. And is it just me, or did Malfoy get another henchman? One of them didn't look familiar, but I'm not sure which one.