Alzrius
The EN World kitten
fba827 said:She commented that she burned down her grandmother's house about X (I didn't hear the number) years ago. IF (and a big if) we draw a couple extra lines, could she be Claire's half-sister (same mother, different father) or cousin (Claire's real mom is a sister to one of Elle's parents). And then Elle would have been adopted by Bob the same way HRG adopted Claire... I know it's reading a lot into the one sentence... but the thing about 'big fire' just seemed to stick in my head. ?
A cool idea, but I don't think so. While Claire would be the right age for that, it'd be Elle's mother's house, not her grandmother's. Also, there would have been something about it in the obituary Claire found (listing just her and her mother in the fire), and her mom and Nathan would have at least mentioned it. It also seems like they explained that fire as being the fault of Firemommy, anyway. Cool theory though.