It is an old meme (from what I understand). That said, I saw it for the first time only a few months ago (I don't keep up on that stuff), so it's still rather fresh for me.
I think the OP did a good job with it. Most of the ones I've seen end up being the editor's rants against things they clearly appear to hate. The vitriol in most of them is readily apparent, and there's usually little to no humor to it. The OP's version didn't fall into that trap, and it was probably the most enjoyable version of that meme I've ever seen.