seasong
First Post
Usually, mmadsen starts this up, but I'm impatient
.
Ground Rules:
0. Check out the Holiday IRON DM thread for the basics.
1. There are no time limits in the Home Game, unless two participants agree to one.
2. I shall critique every entry I can. I am harsh but fair, and unless this thread becomes astoundingly popular, it is unlikely that I will be overwhelmed - I read fast, I write fast, I bleed red ink like a river. Others are encouraged to critique as well, as the goal here is to sharpen our skills.
3. You may choose any ingredient list that has already been "used up". Do not use an ingredient list that is currently being competed with in the Iron DM competition. Once the competitors have finished their scenarios, you're good to go. For a helpful reference, I have compiled all of the lists I know of below.
Have at!
Note: I will be posting my own here as well. If anyone is willing to critique it for me, I'd be most appreciative.
Nemmerle's June 2002 IRON DM
Sample Ingredients List
Carnival
Manticore
Crystal Hypnosis Ball
Stirges
Con Games
Giant Snakes
1st Ingredients List
Bones
Earth Elemental
Ghouls
Magic Key
Kuo-toa
Holy Ground
2nd Ingredients List
Paladin's holy mount
Gargantuan fire beetle
Crippled rogue
Flooded mine
Diary
Intelligent Greatsword
3rd Ingredients List
Amnesia
Island Fortress
Evil Monks
Eggs
Hangman Tree
Cursed Spear, Back-biter
4th Ingredients List
Sundial
Were-bear
Drider
Ring of Elemental Command
Triptych
Butler
5th Ingredients List
Beggars
Corrupt Fire Priest
Defiled Graves
Penitent Undead
Sacred Plants
Tainted Blood
6th Ingredients List
Oval Door
Permanent Image
Quicklings
Female Hill Giant
Staff of Thunder & Lightning
False Beard Made from Dwarf Hair
7th Ingredients List
Tea Party
Opium
Talking Mouse
Murlynd's Spoon
Pixies
Dire Bear
incognito's October 2002 IRON DM
1st Ingredients List
Mountains
Unable to be flanked
Teleport
Ravid
Cold Slaves
Ghost touched spiked gauntlet
2nd Ingredients List
Mushrooms
Dryad
Hand carved pipe
Underground lake
a conflict of interest
Awakened dove - with levels of Ranger
3rd Ingredients List
Wraith w/levels of Bard
Magic ring of irony
A large city
Tasty pudding
The Tree of Knowledge
Barbarian rage
4th Ingredients List
Fine sand
Shadow Dragon or Shadow Dagon
A dead God
Unusual coins
Githzerai Monk
Maintaining balance
5th Ingredients List
Throne of human fat
Rousing music
Fragile mechanical clock
Salamander couriers
Betrayal
1/2 Fiend Xorn
6th Ingredients List
Water table
Gibbous moon
A noble sacrifice
Autumn
Elite kobold knights
Medallion of thoughts
7th Ingredients List
Miniature keep
Potion of Glibness
Champion ogre fighters
Nostalgia
Tome of Hushed Rumors
Mindless Tentacle
8th Ingredients List
Military coup
Priest's sister
Animated violin
Death Slaad
Level playing field
Brilliant energy falcion
(and optional ingredients for bonus points/penalties)
Spell Mastery
Omlette
Worried gnomes
Misleading Map
Quench
Analogy
nemmerle's December 2002 tournament
1st Ingredient List
Wedding gift
Evil grandmother
River Spirit
Lonely Treant
Clock Tower
Ring of Sustenance
2nd Ingredient List
Awakened Rabbit
Rod of Wonder
Briar Patch
Half-Fiend Children
Ankhegs
Barrel of Mead
3rd Ingredient List (TOURNAMENT NOT FINISHED - DO NOT USE)
Angry Halflings
Kazoos
Cavalry
Wishing Well
Hat of Disguise
Hydra
4th Ingredient List (TOURNAMENT NOT FINISHED - DO NOT USE)
Dwarven Bandits
Women’s Clothing
Scroll of Miracle
Simulacrum
Naga
Ancient Monk
OTHERS
HellHound's Ingredient List
Gnome Barbarians
Telekinesis
Seven Flowers
Dire Template
Ancient Crypt
Mercy of the SlaveMaster
Creamsteak's Ingredient List
Action: Lock-picking
Item: A normal samurai sword
Creature: A single hamster
Place: Graveyard
Random: Sacred Tortoise
Random: Grandfather
evileeyore's Ingredients List
Angry Mob
Costume Jewelry
Alchemist’s Fire
Silver Dragon
Foppish Vampire Bard
Apparatus of Kwalish
Hypersmurf's Ingredients List
Nystul's Undetectable Aura
Windmill
Sovereign Glue
Gelatinous Cube
Pathological Liar
Thunderstorm
Pielorinho's Logo Ingredient's List
Rod of Seven Parts
Walrus tusk
Mime
Bugbear wererat
Torn tapestry
Dire Flaming Flail Snail

Ground Rules:
0. Check out the Holiday IRON DM thread for the basics.
1. There are no time limits in the Home Game, unless two participants agree to one.
2. I shall critique every entry I can. I am harsh but fair, and unless this thread becomes astoundingly popular, it is unlikely that I will be overwhelmed - I read fast, I write fast, I bleed red ink like a river. Others are encouraged to critique as well, as the goal here is to sharpen our skills.
3. You may choose any ingredient list that has already been "used up". Do not use an ingredient list that is currently being competed with in the Iron DM competition. Once the competitors have finished their scenarios, you're good to go. For a helpful reference, I have compiled all of the lists I know of below.
Have at!
Note: I will be posting my own here as well. If anyone is willing to critique it for me, I'd be most appreciative.
Nemmerle's June 2002 IRON DM
Sample Ingredients List
Carnival
Manticore
Crystal Hypnosis Ball
Stirges
Con Games
Giant Snakes
1st Ingredients List
Bones
Earth Elemental
Ghouls
Magic Key
Kuo-toa
Holy Ground
2nd Ingredients List
Paladin's holy mount
Gargantuan fire beetle
Crippled rogue
Flooded mine
Diary
Intelligent Greatsword
3rd Ingredients List
Amnesia
Island Fortress
Evil Monks
Eggs
Hangman Tree
Cursed Spear, Back-biter
4th Ingredients List
Sundial
Were-bear
Drider
Ring of Elemental Command
Triptych
Butler
5th Ingredients List
Beggars
Corrupt Fire Priest
Defiled Graves
Penitent Undead
Sacred Plants
Tainted Blood
6th Ingredients List
Oval Door
Permanent Image
Quicklings
Female Hill Giant
Staff of Thunder & Lightning
False Beard Made from Dwarf Hair
7th Ingredients List
Tea Party
Opium
Talking Mouse
Murlynd's Spoon
Pixies
Dire Bear
incognito's October 2002 IRON DM
1st Ingredients List
Mountains
Unable to be flanked
Teleport
Ravid
Cold Slaves
Ghost touched spiked gauntlet
2nd Ingredients List
Mushrooms
Dryad
Hand carved pipe
Underground lake
a conflict of interest
Awakened dove - with levels of Ranger
3rd Ingredients List
Wraith w/levels of Bard
Magic ring of irony
A large city
Tasty pudding
The Tree of Knowledge
Barbarian rage
4th Ingredients List
Fine sand
Shadow Dragon or Shadow Dagon
A dead God
Unusual coins
Githzerai Monk
Maintaining balance
5th Ingredients List
Throne of human fat
Rousing music
Fragile mechanical clock
Salamander couriers
Betrayal
1/2 Fiend Xorn
6th Ingredients List
Water table
Gibbous moon
A noble sacrifice
Autumn
Elite kobold knights
Medallion of thoughts
7th Ingredients List
Miniature keep
Potion of Glibness
Champion ogre fighters
Nostalgia
Tome of Hushed Rumors
Mindless Tentacle
8th Ingredients List
Military coup
Priest's sister
Animated violin
Death Slaad
Level playing field
Brilliant energy falcion
(and optional ingredients for bonus points/penalties)
Spell Mastery
Omlette
Worried gnomes
Misleading Map
Quench
Analogy
nemmerle's December 2002 tournament
1st Ingredient List
Wedding gift
Evil grandmother
River Spirit
Lonely Treant
Clock Tower
Ring of Sustenance
2nd Ingredient List
Awakened Rabbit
Rod of Wonder
Briar Patch
Half-Fiend Children
Ankhegs
Barrel of Mead
3rd Ingredient List (TOURNAMENT NOT FINISHED - DO NOT USE)
Angry Halflings
Kazoos
Cavalry
Wishing Well
Hat of Disguise
Hydra
4th Ingredient List (TOURNAMENT NOT FINISHED - DO NOT USE)
Dwarven Bandits
Women’s Clothing
Scroll of Miracle
Simulacrum
Naga
Ancient Monk
OTHERS
HellHound's Ingredient List
Gnome Barbarians
Telekinesis
Seven Flowers
Dire Template
Ancient Crypt
Mercy of the SlaveMaster
Creamsteak's Ingredient List
Action: Lock-picking
Item: A normal samurai sword
Creature: A single hamster
Place: Graveyard
Random: Sacred Tortoise
Random: Grandfather
evileeyore's Ingredients List
Angry Mob
Costume Jewelry
Alchemist’s Fire
Silver Dragon
Foppish Vampire Bard
Apparatus of Kwalish
Hypersmurf's Ingredients List
Nystul's Undetectable Aura
Windmill
Sovereign Glue
Gelatinous Cube
Pathological Liar
Thunderstorm
Pielorinho's Logo Ingredient's List
Rod of Seven Parts
Walrus tusk
Mime
Bugbear wererat
Torn tapestry
Dire Flaming Flail Snail
Last edited: