Holiday Iron DM!!!! {Final Judgment Posted!}

[Mirth]

Mirthcard: Thanks -- yours is quite good as well!

Thanks. If we keep going like this, then we're gonna be necking like arwink and Rune

Nem: be brutal -- it would not be Iron DM unless it were not pretty!

I think you're pretty, nem.

If that helps. If not, well ... let's be ugly together

 

[incognito]

On Nem's judgements so far (FYI only)

Winner:Arwink

agree

Winner: Wicht

agree

Winner: Quickbeam

agree

It's nice to see judge consistency, anyway...

originally posted by nemmerle
I don't know. . . does that third win count if I was not judge?

Just to confirm, do you no longer want me running the IRON DM competition? I strongly value your opinion, and don't want to step on any toes. And it kinda makes it more official, if I have your blessing.

 

[el-remmen]

Re: On Nem's judgements so far (FYI only)

Just to confirm, do you no longer want me running the IRON DM competition? I strongly value your opinion, and don't want to step on any toes. And it kinda makes it more official, if I have your blessing.

I was just trying to goad Vaxalon into continuing to play - I mean, it is easy to call your champion when you only had to step in and beat one person - not have to win all the way from the beginning and make it to the final round every time. . .

No toes stepped on. . .

 

[seasong]

Top Five Reasons To Play In The Home Game

5. I'm amusing myself there, why aren't you?
4. Remember, there are no losers in the Home Game, just people who wish they were in Iron DM.
3. Nemmerle's only going to critique 14 scenarios by 8 people, and you're probably not one of them.
2. You don't want to see me beg. It's less pretty than a nemmerlesque critique gone horribly wrong.
1. What, you scared or sumthin?

 

[Mirth]

That is some kinda funny, seasong

 

[incognito]

exposition

something I asked for in the last round of IRON DM, and a great way to get into the thoughts of the competitors is asking the wirters for exposition from both the winner and the loser of a round.

So, although I am simply an observer of this IROM DM competition:

I still demand exposition!

ahem.

 

[Zappo]

Exposition?

 

[Quickbeam]

seasong:
If I weren't a competitor in this forum, your comments would have me posting in the Home Game thread .

incognito:
Gimme an idea of what types of remarks and reflective commentary you're seeking, and I'll be happy to oblige.

 

[seasong]

In incognito's IronDM back in October, after each judgement was rendered from on high, the competitors (winner and loser) would explain their reasoning for why they included certain things, or didn't, and otherwise give some insight into why they went the way they did.

 

[Mirth]

I'd be glad to offer some exposition guys, but nem's not done with our battle yet