D&D 5E (2024) How can I do a Charisma-Investigation (or a Strength/Dexterity-Investigation if I can't use Charisma) to find a secret door?

But if the DM does it that way, so you have no choice, it is the only correct way.
As I said, I would leave a game where fading away happened. It's not a game for me. Just like you wouldn't play in my game, because PCs get played when the player misses a game.

It's okay to do things differently, and to really not like how someone else does something.
AND on top of this it is "mentioned" in the rules.
No it isn't. It is mentioned in no rule at all, and being in a rulebook does not make something mentioned in the rules. It has to actually be mentioned in a rule in the rulebook to be mentioned in the rules.
Just admit it! This is the CORRECT way to do this in the game we are talking about in this thread and stop complaining about your opinions or options that don't matter.
I've never said otherwise. And in fact have multiple times said it was fine for you guys. Not once have I said you guys are doing it wrong for your game. Only that it was wrong for me, and then laid out why. It's nonsensical, etc.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

If he is not there and is not going to let anyone play his character then it is going to kill him.
Dude. I'm talking about in my game, clearly. So yes, I would be the one playing him if he was dumb enough to stay in a dungeon all by his lonesome.
It does in the only game that is relevant to this thread.
You don't own the thread or the meanderings it takes. Your game long ago left being the only game that is relevant.
 

Remove ads

Top