D&D 5E (2014) How does the errata on hiding affect the mask of the wild ability of the wood elf?

The latest Basic Rules with the errata, says:

‘You can’t hide from a creature that can see you clearly.’

Thus:

You can hide from a creature that can partially see you.

I'm a bit late to the party here (and someone already replied with the core point), but there's actually a very good reason you can't make this logical leap. That is, first we can re-cast both statements into logical "if-then" form: (1) "If a creature can see you clearly, then you cannot hide from it." (2) "If a creature can partially see you, then you can hide from it." These are statements of the form, "If A, then not-B" and "If C, then B." But C and A are not precise logical complements: A and C are two points on a spectrum. The only way this connection could work is if it was phrased as, "If and only if a creature can see you clearly, then you cannot hide from it." Being clearly seen is a sufficient condition for being unable to hide, but being partially seen is not sufficient for being able to hide.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Enchanted Trinkets Complete

Remove ads

Top