"CR never applies"
Thats a motto in the making. The whole campaign continues in this vein - I didn't want to consistently throw CR 3 encounters at a 3rd level party, I wanted the encounters to reflect the world.
For example, the Balrog is way outta the Fellowship's league (or is it?). Shelob would easily beat Sam on his own, but a lucky critical (and sound tactics) win the day. Where's the fun if every encounter is tailored for you? Bah.
And secondly, I'm a supporter of DnD parties running from something. It happens all the time in fantasy books and films, why not here?
Also, roleplaying is thrusted to the fore, and not what + your sword is.
I could talk a lot more on this, but I'm not going to. I hope you guys agree with me on this - I don't think I'm alone... am I?
[addition!] What did you guys think of the past tense as compared to the present? [addition!]
Spider (Lover of vampiric blades and unforseen side effects)