Jester David
Hero
If it didn't matter WotC wouldn't be saying "no comment".I am really struggling to understand your perspective on this. It's nothing at all like spoiling the Academy Awards - which ARE A COMPETITION. You know, with the competitors all right there, in the room, waiting to hear if they won! If massive impact on their careers, on money, on what else will be made in the future, etc..
Why do you care who announces the date and initial price of the PHB? What could they have "planned" that would make this minor announcement somehow more "major" of an announcement? What on earth were you expecting that would be massively different from what you got?
There simply was nothing at stake here in who makes the announcement and how they made it. It was purely an information dump.
There was no competition here. There is nothing "spoiled" here. There was not "better" message being planned that would somehow make announcing a price and date for a book more "meaningful" than simply announcing the price and date of the book. It's just a friggen price and slightly more specific date of a book for goodness sake!
I am just not understanding why you think this was so major, and how you can go on for days on how important it is that WOTC didn't make this announcement but B&N did. Why do you care, and why is this like spoiling the Oscars for you when most of the rest of us are just talking about the information itself?
The thing is, WotC very much wants information released on their schedule. They very much want to be in control of what we know about their products and when. It's been that way since 4e when they slowly released information at certain times, like dragonborn being core, the changed planes, and the like. By continually teasing information there was always some new topic to talk about which kept the fanbase going for the six months of sparse content prior to release. And if they're in control of our infodumps, we keep going to their website for information and updates, and are exposed to their hype, their marketing. We visit to learn about the release and see teasers of content like, oh, the warlock and sorcerer.
However, they suck at telling us things. And we've seen so much of 5e and have been in a holding patter for so long there much less they can tease us with.
Because WotC is so terrible at this, we get our information elsewhere and the official site has slowly become old news. We all learned about the warlock about it after the Twitch game, before Mearls wrote his article. And everything he "revealed" about the sorcerer was kinda already known after the 24-hour Charity game a few months back. When I want to hear about D&D news I go to ENWorld first, then ICv2, and a couple blogs. And most of the time I hear about news from Twitter first. There's no real reason to visit the D&D site and thus I am unexposed to their hype.
And they've kept us waiting for so long. We've heard "we can't talk about products" for two years. And we really want them to talk about products. And now someone else has come along and beaten them to talking about their own products. So now anything they say on the subject just won't feel as impressive or "must read".