Steel_Wind said:
A pretty damn grim event in the history of Canada to be celebrating it with fireworks, to be sure. (How grim? I would much rather have been landing at Utah beach on June 6 '1944 than on the fields of the Somme on July 1, 1916, thanks very much. It's not even close).
Well, first- comparing the two is largely academic. Both were horrid environments that churned out grisly deaths by the boatload. Both countries should look at the soldiers who willingly stepped into those gauntlets with awe and respect, because none of us will likely ever have to face anything even a tenth as horrid as those battlefields.
Second- there's a matter of scale.
The Somme involved an assault by 24 divisions over virtually one hundred miles on the first day. The commitment of men was well over 300,000. Of those, almost 20,000 died on the battlefield, and another 40,000 suffered significant injury. Patton's rule of thumb was that once a unit suffers 25% casualties it ceases to be a combat-effective unit. On the first day of the Somme, almost two entire British ARMIES suffered 20% casualties. The grisliness was unprecedented.
The landings on Omaha Beach were just as critical, but the battlefield was much, much smaller- the 29th American Infantry division, supported by several companies of Rangers and a tank regiment assaulted an area roughly three miles in length. Even worse, the entire division didn't come on the beach at the same time. Some of the early regiments suffered horrible, horrible casualties- close to 50% dead in many cases. Subsequent landings suffered significant casualties but nothing like the initial assault. Overall, that limited fighting force suffered close to 3,000 deaths.
So where would I rather be? Well, the short answer is nowhere near either of them. The long answer- if we're talking a single day, give me the opening day of the Somme, since I'll have a better chance to survive- especially if I was unlucky enough to be in the opening wave of Omaha. Past that, give me the American Army in WWII- at least things got a little better after the initial landing in Omaha. The British Army was in for much, much worse after July 1st.