Just got my pdf...wow!


log in or register to remove this ad



I just bought the PDF. I really like the illustrations, and it seems well-written, but I have to say I'm pretty disappointed in the first three "quests" included. The very first quest, missing children, is, in my opinion, badly presented and very very simple, lacking a lot of details. Firstly, the only way to find out that the missing child is indeed missing, is to read a sidebar about village gossip. And then there's NO suggested reason for any PC to care about finding the child. No indication it is in danger, just "we dared him and he hasn't come back." Three children are lost, and there are no parents hunting? the sheriff isn't offering a reward? No "lost" posters on the Inn wall? Nothing????

And the villain's motivation is incredibly weak. "He wants to create chaos." Why? Is he seeking revenge? Trying to gain personal power? Does he hate humans? If so, why? If he hates this village in particular, why? What is going on? Nothing? I can't figure it out from what's presented there... I'm going to have to completely invent motives for the villain and for the "helper". I'm saddened by how shallow it is.
 

We should have a deck of NPC cards very soon! 42 cards, one for each of Hengustbury's named residents!
 

I just bought the PDF. I really like the illustrations, and it seems well-written, but I have to say I'm pretty disappointed in the first three "quests" included. The very first quest, missing children, is, in my opinion, badly presented and very very simple, lacking a lot of details. Firstly, the only way to find out that the missing child is indeed missing, is to read a sidebar about village gossip. And then there's NO suggested reason for any PC to care about finding the child. No indication it is in danger, just "we dared him and he hasn't come back." Three children are lost, and there are no parents hunting? the sheriff isn't offering a reward? No "lost" posters on the Inn wall? Nothing????

And the villain's motivation is incredibly weak. "He wants to create chaos." Why? Is he seeking revenge? Trying to gain personal power? Does he hate humans? If so, why? If he hates this village in particular, why? What is going on? Nothing? I can't figure it out from what's presented there... I'm going to have to completely invent motives for the villain and for the "helper". I'm saddened by how shallow it is.

It sounds like ZEITGEIST is your thing! TSAD is, as you observed, quite simple. :)
 

Zeitgeist would be more my thing if it was medieval and non-steampunk...

I never seem to get both deep plot and complex storyline and a setting I like in combination! Which is why I buy products like TSaD - I will be using it for my online DungeonWorld campaign, and for that it will be perfect - lots of room for the players to spout knowledge, to answer unanswered questions, and to reshape the world the way we want it to be.

Don't get me wrong about TSaD - I think the setting is great - the writeup of Hengistbury and the surroundings are wonderful. All the NPCs are terrific. I've already decided to add a village school for the kids to go to, and that Lady Sibyl is responsible for appointing the teacher; the first hint that kids are missing will be when the teacher discovers that 3 of her kids didn't show up for school one day, and reports it to the sheriff; all 3 are feared to have gone swimming in Mill Pond, because of something one child says; so the adults are all searching there, while the brothers Mortimer are hunting for Ugg to beg him to accompany them into the woods to rescue Poke and his friends.

The PCs will arrive in town during the beginnings of the pond-dragging, and perhaps will see Ugg and the boys sneaking away...
 


A quick mockup of the NPC cards. Which is ironic, because we'll be doing them through RPGNow's PoD system, which doesn't actually provide a tuck box. So this image is just for fun.
 

Attachments

  • TSaD_tuckbox_sample.jpg
    TSaD_tuckbox_sample.jpg
    33.4 KB · Views: 186

I purchased the ap this morning. This ap looks very exciting! I'm planning on running it before I run Zeitgeist. Ill be ready to run it in maybe 3 months from now, definately will keep up a campaign thread :D
 

Remove ads

Top