Magic of incarnum ir Epic Level Handbook

[Wombat]

Neither. I don't use epic rules for post-level-20 play, and MoI was just a little too much added to what would have been a decent single article.

QFT

 

[D.Shaffer]

Magic of Incarnum for me.
I love me some Totemists. Although, I think the other classes could use a bit of work to make them more distinctive.

 

[gamecat]

I hated incarnum at first, but now I'm quite warm to it.

The ELHB, as cool as it was, is just PHB^2.

 

[Crothian]

ELH: dispite its many flaws it is useful for everyone once you reach 21st level. MoI just a few quirky ideas that some people take to but doesn't expand on the whole game like ELH.

 

[Whizbang Dustyboots]

There are monsters in the ELH that I suspect will end up being part of every future edition of D&D, like the Worm that Walks and the Abominations.

Heck, if you play through one of the adventure paths from Paizo, you come face to face with one of these in a climactic moment, suggesting that classic status may already be on the way.

 

[AdmundfortGeographer]

Incarnum and Upper_Krust's epic level rules.

 

[zimdanen]

ELH. I don't like veering too entirely far from core, and Incarnum certainly is far. I've never had an epic level character, but I've been in love with the concept of starting at level 1 and moving to extreme powers at a steady and reasonable pace - fully developing a character. As such, I'd love to have the chance to use the ELH.

 

[Quickleaf]

Incarnum and Upper_Krust's epic level rules.

You mean the Immortals Handbook or something else?

 

[Stone Dog]

ELH: dispite its many flaws it is useful for everyone once you reach 21st level. MoI just a few quirky ideas that some people take to but doesn't expand on the whole game like ELH.

I would never use the ELH for anything, personally. EVER. 21st level easily has better options out there than that book.

MoI for me, please.

 

[Lord Rasputin]

Epic. Incarnum really should have been a section in Tome of Magic, and frankly, D&D needs another cap system like it needs a return to damage by foe size for weapons. Epic plays like D&D-flavored superheroes, which is a nice change-of-pace. I hate superheroes normally, but epic D&D is always fun.