Voadam
Legend
Insight said:OK here's the idea (this one also gives the group a bit of backstory).
A Tiefling Rogue who has always been the black sheep of the party. A while back, he was captured and held by the Scarlet Brotherhood. He returned to the party a few years later a completely changed man. While he still makes use of his skills at stealth and intrusion, he is equally proficient with deception and unarmed combat. And no one quite knows what he's thinking. All they can see is a strange ritual tattoo on his chest, a white mask...
Odd as he may seem, and not at all the same happy go lucky scoundrel who was captured all those years ago, he has a renewed sense of purpose, and can still be quite a useful member of the party when he wants to. Note that he has never done anything to harm anyone in the group, though his methods are sometimes ruthlessly efficient and occasionally self serving.
Did we rescue you from the brotherhood?
Just make sure he does not detect as evil because it would be the first thing I'd check. And if you showed as evil I would work to rescue you from the changes they inflicted upon you. I plan on using detect evil as a detect enemies type of power at doors, having you trip it would spoil that (in addition to the paladin stuff).