JoeGKushner said:
I get ya but with all the blogs and boards they have, does one of the 'official' editorial style articles have to be hype about hype?
I don't interpret a lot of what these guys are saying as hype. I realize that's totally subjective on my part, but I see this as enthusiasm.
This is literally (especially for the guys in charge of the new edition) a once in a career opportunity. If I was them, you would not be able to shut me up with a straightjacket and a gag.
And based on what he's saying, it conflicts with what we've heard from other sources that said not much would be revealed in these early books.
I don't think much mechanics WILL be released in these books. The only thing he confirmed was "you'll find out the 8th race". I don't consider that much.
But certainly, SOME stuff will be revealed.
I see these books as part of a trend recently to offer very select marketing to the hardest of the hardcore in your fanbase.
EA did a pay per view special about the new Madden game last year. A lot of folks were appalled at that too, just like these books. But I don't see any harm. If they were bundled with the PHB, at an increased price, it would be one thing. But these are strictly optional items.
What's next? Next month talking about how right they were about the hype?
I think what's next is, as Bill alluded to "the beginnings of more concrete information". I suspected that they were waiting for the holidays to be over and everyone to be un-distracted before they started the big reveals.
Turns out they were waiting to incorporate playtest info.
Either way, I think we're now heading into the "this is what we're doing" stage and away from the "I can't tell you anything concrete, man am I *pumped*" stage.