gfunk said:
Re: the AoP/MT class combo
You must realize, of course, that your spell selection will be extremely limited by default. As per the Vow of Peace guidelines you may not inflict lethal damage, ability damage or drain, or spells that cause death on any living creature.
There are feats to deal with that. Subdual Substitution would become a way of life for you. ^_^
gfunk said:
You cannot even Hold foes so that your friends can coup-de-grace them. Both of the above would cause you to irrevocably lose the benefits of your vow.
Unless you knew your friends respected your vows, and would never CDG with
lethal damage (as opposed to just K.O.'ing them).
And against Undead, the kid gloves can come off -- vow of Peace les you slam undead all you want. Constructs too, for that matter; they aren't ALIVE, they're just magical
machines.
gfunk said:
Therefore, the spells that remain either allow you to (a) buff/heal your allies or yourself and (b) contain your foes without hurting them or putting them in grave danger. For example, spells like Resilient Sphere and Yoke of Mercy would fit into this category.
Constricting Chains would also fit. Nonlethal Damage doesn't violate the Vow of Peace, nor the Vow of Nonviolence. IOW, you can beat someone into unconsciousness ... as long as you're reasonably sure they'll live through the experience. ^_^
gfunk said:
My point is, simply, that from a powergaming perspective the AoP/MT combo isn't what it appears on paper. If you compare it to an Ur-Priest/MT combo then, I think, you will gain some perspective.
It is, and it isn't. You have to, as a player, REALLY try hard to thnk of ways to be effective in the many inevitable combats that will arise, other than injuring the enemy, or helping your allies hurt them.
And FWIW ... I'd tend to think that making your allies stronger in combat would be "helping them injure others", unless you could extract a solemn (and reliable) oath from them to "do no harm" (IOW, attack to subdue). ^_^ Thus, Bull's Strength wouldn't be a good idea.
OTOH, End to Strife would be a GRAND spell to cast. ^_^ "Go ahead, stick your knife into me, and feel your just punishment!"