D&D 5E [OCC] Against the Slavelords PBP

[TallIan]

Hmm I will re-read it again tonight but I don't think it say melee attack does it? Just that if you have a one handed weapon...

It says, "take the attack action", but Kahles, and I've seen others, argue that it should be melee RAI.

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

 

[GreenKarl]

RAI? Being dense here don't remember what that is

 

[TallIan]

Rules As Intended as opposed to Rules As Written.

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

 

[GreenKarl]

Hmmm maybe but I can see both ways which is why I am not 100% opposed to it being either way. Let me re-read the feat tonight when I get home from work

 

[BlueLotus]

Yeah. Lucky is very nice. I'm thinking of taking that myself. But I wonder how much of a pain it would be to use in PbP vs live.

 

[GreenKarl]

Well Lucky is based on per Day right? Basically its every long rest. You would have to track them yourselves as the GM I would not If you are using the EN Roller you would have to either go back and edit your post to use one if you did not like the roll result or post it in a follow up post. It would not be too big a deal for me I don't think but anyone with it would have to track it...

 

[BlueLotus]

The second part though, for messing with enemy rolls, seems like it would just add on more time and editing hassle between combat rounds

But I already like the feat just for the rerolls for yourself. I'll go with it and try to keep enemy rerolls at a minimum.

 

[GreenKarl]

Oh yea... hmm I could see in that case you would have to declare before the attack roll... saying "If that guy (or anyone) hits me I want it to be re-rolled" Or you could say "Any critical hits against me please re-rolls"

 

[TallIan]

I think that's what makes it troublesome in PbP. You can choose to use luck after seeing the result of the roll, but in PbP that could take three days to resolve.

 

[Scotley]

Seriously, we haven't spoken much about treasure. I favor even distribution with items of power going to those who can use them best. One of the cloaks is a natural for Kelvyn. He would hang on to a crossbow as a spare and a vial of the poison as well. As it is not deadly, at least not directly he feels it is acceptable to use.