These are the Items, with what is known about them, as well as Tristans items. I suggest (ie. not command) you just take turns and pick one till they are all gone. As soon as noone wants any of the items, you can try and sell the rest and divide the money.
if you go with this method, I have randomly generated (d1000) an order, High to low
Diactum: 794
Deepwinter: 775
Ilan: 583
Wulf: 44
Items:
- Leather Bracers, worn by Hobgoblin Corpse (obstructed by Iron bands)
- Tough, high quality grey cloak, worn by Hobgoblin Corpse: Cloak of Resistance +1 (obstructed by Iron bands)
- Steel Buckler, worn by Hobgoblin Corpse. Magic aura is weak - Buckler +1 (obstructed by Iron bands)
- Fine threaded Black Cloak of Resistance +2
- Simple wooden Wand tipped with a ruby: Wand of Fireballs (DC ?, Command Word ?, Charges ?, ?d6)
- Simple but well balanced +1 Light Flail
- Fine soft leather brown boots, Boots of Sneaking (move silently +?)
- Tough, high quality Cloak of Resistance +1
- Gold ring with small blue gemstone: Ring of Protection +1.
- Tough, high quality grey cloak, worn by Hobgoblin cleric. More powerful aura than the other grey cloaks.
- +1 Large Wooden Shield, painted pitch black
- +1 Orcish Great Scimitar
- +1 Full Plate, has been dented many times
- Tough, high quality grey Cloak of Resistance +1
- +1 Chainshirt
- +1 Longsword
- Iron bands of Bilarro
- Gauntlets of ogre power (+2 strength)
- Boots of striding and springing (errata: maximum of +30 enhancement bonus to movement rate up to your normal movement rate, +10 to jump checks.)
- Gardi's Collection of Arcane spells Volume I
- Gardi's Collection of Arcane spells Volume II
Potions:
- Cure Light Wounds (3x)
- Cure Moderate Wounds (1x)
- Invisibility (3x)
- Invisibility (empty vial) (1x)
Non Magical Items (and their GP worth):
- Masterwork Mighty Composite Longbow, +4 Strength bonus (1000 gp). Extra Hard wood as well as intricate designs makes it 200 gp more expensive than normal (bow has +2 hp).
- Masterwork Chain Shirt (250 gp)
- Masterwork Small Chain Shirt (250 gp)
- Full Plate (1500 gp)
- Masterwork Longsword (315 gp)
- Masterwork Battleaxe (circa 310 gp)
- 4 Daggers (4 x 2 gp)
- Silver Holy Symbol (25 gp)
- Large Steel shield, Looks very battered (20 gp)
- 5 Throwing Axes (can't be bothered to look the price up )
Cold Hard Cash:
10 Platinum pieces, 685 gold pieces, 202 silver pieces.