jgsugden
Legend
There is a harp and singing competition in the village. Three PCs enter. All are the same level and have the same charisma.
Tim (PC 1) has proficiency with the harp and proficiency with performance. Tom (PC 2) has proficiency in harp, but not performance. Tam (PC) has proficiency in performance, but not harp. The DM asks all three players to describe their performances and all three independently give similar descriptions.
As a DM, how would you handle the situation? All three make the same roll because they're all proficient in something relevant and have the same bonuses? Or does Tim get an advantage for having both performance and harp proficiency? If so, what is that bonus?
Tim (PC 1) has proficiency with the harp and proficiency with performance. Tom (PC 2) has proficiency in harp, but not performance. Tam (PC) has proficiency in performance, but not harp. The DM asks all three players to describe their performances and all three independently give similar descriptions.
As a DM, how would you handle the situation? All three make the same roll because they're all proficient in something relevant and have the same bonuses? Or does Tim get an advantage for having both performance and harp proficiency? If so, what is that bonus?