Please rate the Dirty Fighting feat

[Mortaneus]

Here's the version I use in my campaign:

Dirty Fighting

Gives +2 to opposed checks when making a disarm, grapple, or trip attempt.

 

[Plane Sailing]

I prefer my version of Dirty Fighting which I introduced before S&F appeared.

prereq: BAB 4+
Benefit: +1d6 sneak attack. Usable just like sneak attack ability of rogues, which it stacks with.
Special: This can only be taken once

I consider the S&F version worthless.

Cheers

 

[jontherev]

I prefer my version of Dirty Fighting which I introduced before S&F appeared.

prereq: BAB 4+
Benefit: +1d6 sneak attack. Usable just like sneak attack ability of rogues, which it stacks with.
Special: This can only be taken once

I consider the S&F version worthless.

Cheers

Oooooo...now that's dirty! I like it!

 

[Gromm]

Here's the version I use in my campaign:

Dirty Fighting

Gives +2 to opposed checks when making a disarm, grapple, or trip attempt.

I like the idea, though disarm might be a little out of character in some ways, but it could still work. Makes more sense that it should help one in say, a barroom brawl where you're using tables and the like vs a dungeon corridor where everyone is probably fighting "dirty" by trying to kill the other guy however possible (held or prone? sounds like an easy target).

 

[smetzger]

bump

 

[gamecat]

Why not adjust dirty fighting so that when the full attack is taken, each attack deals +1d4?

By the way, smetzger, don't posts links to your irritating surveys in other forums.

 

[smetzger]

By the way, smetzger, don't posts links to your irritating surveys in other forums.

I believe that this is the correct way to crosspost. No moderator has complained. However, I will make a note in the subject line for future posts.

 

[Quickbeam]

I voted "good" because one of my players took the feat, and it's "good" for my monsters and nasty fellows that he essentially wasted a feat . Seriously, he seems to like Dirty Fighting as written, but IMO that's primarily because it's how he'd behave IRL.

 

[theridion]

improved dirty fighting? i have not seen that in the FAQ for sword and fist, and i can't find it in there now. can you give me a link to find it or the official faq or list the feat hear?

 

[smetzger]

improved dirty fighting? i have not seen that in the FAQ for sword and fist, and i can't find it in there now. can you give me a link to find it or the official faq or list the feat hear?

Its in the D&D FAQ not the S&F errata.