D&D 5E (2024) Snarf's Complete Two Weapon Fighting and Grappling Guide

[UngeheuerLich]

I have a question:

I think there is a way to read the light and nick property that you don't need the feat at all:
The light weapon property is on both weapons. So both weapons could enable a second attack with the other weapon if used during the attack action. The light property never states that it can only be used once per turn.

Using two nick weapons might even allow two nick attacks, depending on the reading.

Another reading allows only ONE bonus action action per attack action. And nick just changes the action economy) Then using action surge at least should allow for one extra light weapon property attack at least. (Which I think is a better reading).

 

[Plaguescarred]

I don't see any way to read as ever making more than one extra attack of the Light property, with or without Nick mastery, it's the same done as part of the Attack action instead of a Bonus Action, and is limited to once per turn wether it does or not.

I also think it's possible to equip and unequip one weapon when you make any attack with the Attack action, not just one per Attack action. Likewise you can equip a Thrown weapon everytime you attack with one. You also have one free item interaction as part of your action or movement.

 

[Horwath]

A Duel-Wielding Fighter with Extra Attack(4)+Light/Nick+Action Surge seems NUTTY!

it's really not,
TWF is actually worst style for a fighter.
you only get one extra "off hand" attack, and even if you take the feat(that anyone can take) you still get only one extra attack as Bonus action.