[Poll] Your favorite edition for Castle Zagyg

[GQuail]

I voted AD&D first edition, but really, any of the systems in the "TSR D&D and simulacra" family would be all right. Cross-compatibility is high, and they share a similar design philosophy/implied play style.

I would not feel comfortable with a 3e, 4e or LA version; Zagyg just isn't for those kinds of games.

Despite my personal preference for the modern systems (although I keep threatning to run 1E/BECMI for my group), I think I agree with you. Castle Zagyg isn't just a dungeon crawl, it's the dungeon crawl and using the older-styled rules-sets for it sends a very important message on how it should be approached.

 

[xechnao]

I voted other.

I think Castle Zagyg should be a system unto itself. Use the OGL and build a system that supports Mr. Gugax's vision, and include that in the "box" or "book" or what have you.

Agreed.