Rate Revenge of the Sith *SPOILERS*

[Darth K'Trava]

Hey man! Screw Lucas and the tauntaun he rode in on!

 

[Truth Seeker]

Why not Thursday at a little after 2:20AM?

No...I feel nasty , friday....just friday.

 

[Arnwyn]

WUSS!!

Nah. Think "apathy".

 

[Jakar]

Saw it about 8 hours ago here in Australia. Good but not great. The look rates a 10 but the acting and the script only get about a 3 from me.

 

[Bass Puppet]

I saw it last night.

Visually...it's absolutely beautiful, but I would have liked to see more set design like in the OT as apose to MORE C.G.I. . I thought Lucas tried to cram to much into this one, but it did flow, just very quickly. The acting was better (maybe because their was less) between Hayden and Portman...but not much. Yoda rocks. The Music was great! Ian McDiarmid is amazing in this.

Quint from aint it cool news said it best.

"REVENGE OF THE SITH is worth getting excited about, but it's not perfect... however, compared to the first two ROTS is damn near a masterpiece of modern cinema. You'll have a good time and for those of us burned by the other prequels... it'll finally feel like you're watching a STAR WARS film again. Thank God."

 

[Digital M@]

I saw it last night.

I thought Lucas tried to cram to much into this one, but it did flow, just very quickly. The acting was better (maybe because their was less) between Hayden and Portman...but not much. Yoda rocks. The Music was great! Ian McDiarmid is amazing in this.

This is my opinion as well. IMO, he took two movies for basic setup and one movie focuses on what the whole trilogy should have focused on. He could of had so much more depth to everything without kiddie Vader in Ep I. It kinda makes me sad he missed the mark by so much. I think maybe he had visions of certain scenes and created the movies around those visions instead of working one long story board up and then dividing it into three films.

 

[KenM]

I just got back from midnight showing. I gave it a 8. Really good sci fi flick. Best Star Wars since Empire. But I also think Lucas tryed to put too much into this one. If he spread it out, we could have had more devolpment with some of the secondary characters. (Mace Windu, Bail Organia, Dooku, ect.)

 

[Aeson]

Vast improvement of the previous two. For is saying a lot because I liked them. My faith in Star Wars has been restored.

 

[Insight]

Go see it. I'm not going to do any spoilers. Just go see it. Well worth whatever effort it takes you. Answers all of the questions, and is one hell of a fine movie. Oh, and one small spolier - Artoo kicks ass!

 

[Ankh-Morpork Guard]

Also just got back. Great. And yes, Artoo is even better than ever.

At this point, I put Sith behind only Empire. Everything was just...just...I'm too tired to make sense of it, and I need to see it again to take in everything.

Before I go to bed though...look for the Millenium Falcon(or a generic YT-1300, but we KNOW which ship it really is)

EDIT: Forgot to mention...I give it a 9. Only not a 10 due to some really bad dialogue(mostly all on Portman's part...Hayden did great as Anakin), but that was kind of expected anyway.