I'm not surprised that you (collectively) don't know Vault of the Dracolich, but I AM somewhat surprised that no one is very familiar with Forge of Fury - unless someone is who hasn't spoken up yet.
At any rate, I'm leaning toward Vault Redux. Vault of the Dracolich was Level Four (single session) but let's still start by making Level 3 characters, and I'll level you up liberally (probably to Level 5 by the end). We'll pick parties after everyone has made characters. In fact, we'll start the game with one really big party, and split them up into groups as part of the story. It could go as many as three (small) groups, I think, if it makes sense to do so.
I'd like to start soonish, so let's get those characters made!
A few notes: Use one of these ability arrays (or ask me for another):
15/14/13/12/10/8
14/14/13/12/10/10
15/15/12/11/10/8
15/13/12/12/11/10
If you want to use anything that isn't in 2024 yet (like Warforged), feel free to use the old version. If a 2024 version shows up while we're playing, you can chose to rebuild it if you like. If you don't have 2024 stuff, it's not a huge big deal if you use the 2014 version, but we'll default to 2024 if a conflict arises (I probably won't notice any conflicts). I generally feel that as long as everyone is playing in good faith, it doesn't matter if we do everything perfectly by the book.