Micah Sweet
Level Up & OSR Enthusiast
Ok, then I don't really agree. 3.5 is different enough from 3.0 to count as a new edition to me. It's certainly has more changes than 1e to 2e IMO, and those are definitively separate editions. To me, 5.0 and 5.5 fall into the same 1e to 2e category so far as how much has changed. In some cases more so, what with all the classes being re-written and the sweeping lore replacements.Half-editions aren't a thing. They are versions of the same edition or they are a new edition. 3.5 is either part of 3e OR it's really 4e. I can't make that any clearer.
But of course, all both of us are discussing are subjective personal opinions.