Retroactive Barbarian Variant

[Rae ArdGaoth]

As I've mentioned in the General Discussion thread, I recently went over the Barbarian Totem variants in detail and noticed that the Horse Totem fits my dwarven barbarian Rasereit perfectly. His only friend for many years was a horse, Ride is his only maxed out skill, and he has always had a horse at his side. He also seems to end up running around the place lot.

The abilities being replaced would be Uncanny Dodge and Trap Sense (Though he's L6, he's only Brb 4, so no Improved Uncanny yet). Trap Sense he's never used, and I can't honestly remember a time where Uncanny Dodge was used. He has nearly died twice, once on the Island of Varras'zul against a swarm of invincible demon bugs, and once in Niobe's Dilemma against a group of 5 criminals. Neither time did he benefit from Uncanny Dodge.

I'm willing to spend DM credits on this change, if that's desired. I think an appropriate amount would be equal to the XP spent in a Psychic Reformation. Since Razh is L6, he'd need 300 XP for himself + 300 XP for the manifester, so 2 DM credits.

 

[Bront]

I'd rather you just get a Psychic Reformation (It would cost him money to find someone to do it too). But I have no problem if you do that. It'd just cost the equivilent of a 4th level power manifested by a 7th level caster with no XP if you spend the extra credit, though you might need to find someone to do it.

 

[Trouvere]

Does the change necessarily have to be retroactive? He's currently by default a jaguar totem barbarian. The RAW says "The choice of a totem must be taken at 1st level, and cannot be changed later except under extreme circumstances (such as the barbarian being adopted by another tribe)."

Throw some extreme circumstances at him, Manzanita!

 

[orsal]

Does the change necessarily have to be retroactive? He's currently by default a jaguar totem barbarian. The RAW says "The choice of a totem must be taken at 1st level, and cannot be changed later except under extreme circumstances (such as the barbarian being adopted by another tribe)."

Throw some extreme circumstances at him, Manzanita!

Does the lack of options available at the time the character was created constitute an extreme circumstance?

 

[Rae ArdGaoth]

The example given by the rules is the barbarian being adopted by another tribe. Rasereit probably started out as a Jaguar Totem barbarian, then he left home and met his horse friend, and then he got to level 2. That second level would surely have been taken in Horse Totem barbarian, had the variant been approved.

It's still a retroactive change, though, and a year after the variant was approved. Interestingly, I was the one who pointed out that Wyrmslayer's initial proposal was incorrectly copied, and I copied the correct variants over from the SRD.

Probably my thought process was this: Hm, totem barbarians, these look neat. Oh, horse totem! What, no fast movement +10'? That's dumb, no thanks. Wait, that's wrong, wait, a bunch of these are wrong. I'll fix them. Now what was I thinking about before this? Oh well.

The totems were approved with the allowance of current barbarians to change retroactively, and Rasereit has yet to gain a level in barbarian since the totems were approved...

 

[Bront]

That's a different issue then. I didn't realize we made an allowance to change retroactively in the proposal.

 

[Rae ArdGaoth]

Sorry, I didn't mean to be unclear. I said Rasereit hasn't taken any levels in barbarian, but what I meant to say was "Rasereit has taken levels in fighter, but not any in barbarian."

 

[Manzanita]

Sounds like we should let Razh make the change.

 

[Erekose13]

ao'Thuir retroactively changed to one of these after his adventure had concluded. It was allowed then, though he has since retired without adventuring again so it never really came up.

 

[Rae ArdGaoth]

So, we have a consensus? Should I request 3 official judge votes, or does this fall under the retroactive change provision of the totem proposal?