Return of the Edition War

[Invisible Stalker]

Maybe we just need some new ones?

Let's have 2e and 4e fans fight it out while the 1e and 3e fans snipe at each other.

 

[JohnRTroy]

No, it comes from the definition of third party.

The first party is the seller, WoTC. The second party is us, the consumer.

Third Party means somebody else who ends up getting involved in the chain. The term third party is somebody who ends up making complementary or supplementary products that are somehow dependent on the first party's creation.

 

[Mikaze]

I'm long past tired of people trying to get their digs in on each others gaming choices and knowingly stirring the pot. They know who they are.

On Topic: Diablo 2 was the superior edition. Diablo 3 is all rainbows and cartoony OH MY GOD IT'S RUINED FOREVER.

 

[Piratecat]

Let's have 2e and 4e fans fight it out.

Bizarrely, I just had this discussion with an old friend I'd gotten back in touch with. I had mentioned that I liked playing 4e, and he said that he had hated 3e and still played a house-ruled version of 2e.

Honestly, I wasn't quite sure what to say.

 

[Sammael]

I don't get it. It is very obvious that yes one game is better then the other. It doesn't matter what people think, the facts are thus: Changeling the Dreaming is better then Changeling the Lost.

Trolling points+++

(Changeling the Dreaming was a failure; Changeling the Lost is - rightfully - considered to be one of the best NWoD games)

 

[Hereticus]

Return of the Edition War

I've seen several threads in the past week devolve into fairly vitriolic edition wars. Seems to me we had quite a long period of relative civility and good discussion. Things seem to be coming loose again. Maybe it's just me.

There are differences between Fourth Edition and earlier editions.

Why must every comment that mentions a difference be labeled WAR?

 

[Invisible Stalker]

Bizarrely, I just had this discussion with an old friend I'd gotten back in touch with. I had mentioned that I liked playing 4e, and he said that he had hated 3e and still played a house-ruled version of 2e.

Honestly, I wasn't quite sure what to say.

One of my players is a big 2e fan, and that's the one edition I don't like. Thankfully, we both enjoy 4e.

 

[Odhanan]

Trolling points+++

(Changeling the Dreaming was a failure; Changeling the Lost is - rightfully - considered to be one of the best NWoD games)

Bah! Both of these games are failures! Promethean: the Created wins by comparison, in any case!

 

[Crothian]

(Changeling the Dreaming was a failure; Changeling the Lost is - rightfully - considered to be one of the best NWoD games)

Those are fighting words. I've successful had great multi year CtD campaigns. It was only a failure to people who were consumed by banality and truly dead inside.

 

[Eridanis]

Over to Meta you go.