Mistwell
Crusty Old Meatwad
Well, yes, the whip does count as a reach weapon, it has reach after all, it just doesn't count as a polearm, which is reasonable. I'm tempted to brew up a separate feat for the whip now that I think about though - I think there are some cool things that could be done there.
Sorry you're right. It's a reach weapon, just not a polearm. And it does deserve it's own feat.
I think a lot of weapons didn't get a feat that ought to. Like the dagger - how is there no dagger feat that allows an effective dagger-thrower PC? I've wanted one since day 1 release.