Shamans (MONGOOSE) vs Shamans (GREEN RONIN) - Anyone's experience yet?

[UD]

So now you've spent large quantities of money on two books. i certainly hope there are a lot of shamans in your game....

I just can't bring myself to buy extremely specific books like this, they just never seem to get enough use to justify their price, no matter how cool they are.

There will be, oh yes... there will...

Also I tend to buy everything that Mongoose and GR publish 'cos its generally top-notch! In both of these cases there both great! Having read tehm a bit more now I would say that the GR book would be very good for anyone who wants to bring a sorcerer-like cleric into there campaign, and the MG book focuses more on what a traditional Shaman is like. The MG book offers a huge rp element and your imagination just crawls with ideas reading that book, but in the end I think Im going to mix and match!

 

[Psion]

Simon's review of ED: Shamans is now up.