ChrisCarlson
First Post
So, as part of his declared action to turn the dial, he is also verbalizing and narrating his character's "dumb logic" idea as justification for all to hear? I see.Take your example, but the player actually roleplays turning it to S for smart instead of having to be asked.
Seems a solid way to make sure no zinger roleplaying moments, like the one in my example, can ever play out at your table. And for that I feel bad for you and your players. Truly. Because its instances like the one in my example that we play for: memorable interactions, joyous revelations/discoveries, and clever roleplaying moments that make everyone smile and laugh.
Your method would appear to have killed any chance of that happening.