billd91
Not your screen monkey (he/him) 🇺🇦🇵🇸🏳️⚧️
Altalazar said:What you call "stacking the decks" I call creating a character. When you let the dice decide for you, letting "fate" decide, you are no longer the one creating the character. That is just some steps removed from just being handed a pre-made character from the DM. That would also be "playing the hand dealt to you" - and for some, that may be fine, but when I create a character, I'd rather take an active part in it rather than passively being given what a random number generator has decided what my character will be.
Of course you ARE creating the character. You're deciding how the character would react to various situations, you're deciding the character's motivations, you're deciding the character's personality. If you really want to say that rolling the stats is just some steps removed from playing a pre-made character from the DM, then using point buy to pick the stats is only ONE further step away... and a very minor step at that since a character is far more than just a collection of 6 stats.