One script review, or are there more in agreement with that assessment?
If it is, then it may be a terrible setback for the guy who has previously written the award-winning Gladiator.
As for the director Stuart Baird, I don't know what to think of him. He has no knowledge of past Trek continuity and was constantly educated by the TNG cast, according to Marina Sirtis ("Counselor Troi").
Of course, the introduction of the mysterious Remans who live on Romulus' sister planet of Remus threw me for a loop. You would think that the Federation would know of them since they have the technology of long-distance snooping. I mean, IIRC, they were able to get an image of Ambassador Spock on Romulus (Leonard Nimoy guest-starred in one of TNG episodes, "Reunification").