Star Wars d20: Consular vs. Guardian

[Khorod]

Its not too powerful, it is exactly as powerful as its supposed to be
Power balance is irrelevant outside of multi-player RPGs where people want to do different things. The KotOR games model Jedi power levels relative to other people fairly cleanly.

 

[Ranger REG]

My problem with this has been that a Jedi Guardian has more "force fuel" than a Conselor does. It makes sense to me when comparing Jedi to non-Jedi, but when comparing Consulars to Guardians, the lack of VP makes Consulars fall flat in my opinion.

Of that I agree. Both JG and JC should have the same vitality die (I recommend d8). Only their BAB and Class Defense Bonus should differ, since JG are more militant and JC are more contemplative.

I also think skill allotment should be more beneficial to JC than to JG because of the focus of their training. Throw in the ability to reduce vitality cost per power activation, and JC can be as potent as JG but in other area.