D&D 5E Survivor Campaign Settings II: Blackmoor Wins!

[rgoodbb]

Blackmoor 18
Dark Sun 8
Eberron 6
Greyhawk 12
Kingdoms of Kalamar 12
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 17
Spelljammer 13

 

[Gradine]

Blackmoor 18
Dark Sun 8
Eberron 7
Greyhawk 12
Kingdoms of Kalamar 10
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 17
Spelljammer 13

The idea of any of these settings falling before some random 3pp nobody seems to really be into (I hear it's super geographically sound, or something? And the setting for the actually playable version of Hackmaster, I guess?) seems absurd to me. I may like the newer, genre-twistier settings on this list much better than Grognardia #1, #2, #3 and #4, but at least I can recognize those settings as forming the foundation of the game (and I've, you know, heard of them).

I'm calling Blackmoor as the eventual winner as it currently leads despite the fact that there is only one person who has given it any upvotes so far.

 

[Bolares]

Blackmoor 18
Dark Sun 8
Eberron 8
Greyhawk 12
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 17
Spelljammer 13

 

[Tony Vargas]

I'm calling Blackmoor as the eventual winner as it currently leads despite the fact that there is only one person who has given it any upvotes so far.

We can up-vote for any reason, no matter how tenuous or stupid, I consider it a proxy for under-appreciated D&D co-creator Dave Arneson.

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 6
Eberron 8
Greyhawk 12
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 17
Spelljammer 13

 

[Lanefan]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 6
Eberron 6
Greyhawk 12
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13

Yeah, of what's left my second choice would be Blackmoor. All the other ones I care about are long gone.

 

[Grakarg]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 6
Eberron 4
Greyhawk 13
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13

 

[Ed Laprade]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 6 -2 = 4.
Eberron 4
Greyhawk 13 +1 = 14.
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13

 

[Zaxarus]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 4
Eberron 4
Greyhawk 14 + 1 = 15
Kingdoms of Kalamar 8 - 2 = 6
Lankhmar 16
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13

 

[PabloM]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 4
Eberron 4
Greyhawk 13
Kingdoms of Kalamar 6
Lankhmar 17
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13

 

[Harzel]

Blackmoor 19
Dark Sun 5
Eberron 4
Greyhawk 11
Kingdoms of Kalamar 6
Lankhmar 17
Mystara 18
Spelljammer 13