Survivor D&D Computer Games- Baldur's Gate WINS!

[Tyler Do'Urden]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 13
Icewind Dale 11
Neverwinter Nights 16
Neverwinter Nights II 19

Planescape: Torment 11​

 

[Sacrosanct]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 13
Icewind Dale 11
Neverwinter Nights 16
Neverwinter Nights II 20
Planescape: Torment 9

 

[Sacrosanct]

Torment should be winning this hands down.

Edgelords gonna edge.

Despite your personal insult at people who don't agree with your opinion Gladius, there's a pretty good reason for it.

The simple answer is Planescape does not represent what D&D is, or what people think of when they hear D&D.

Torment has been widely regarded as a great game, but are you telling me the game that should "win hands down" to represent D&D is a game that you can't even play a human, dwarf, elf, or halfling or have one in your party? That instead your party is Johhny Blaze, a floating skull, and a toaster? THAT represents D&D? Or a game that is little more than an interactive story should represent a game that is known for being built around combat? Or a game where you can change your class pretty much whenever you want when nothing like that remotely exists in the actual game it pulls it's name from?

No, I vote it down because I think the best D&D game should actually be part of the genre that D&D is iconic for: high fantasy, and at least have most of the same features and feel between the actual TTRPG, and the video game that represents it. It has nothing to do with me just trying to be edgy.

 

[Gradine]

Edgelords gonna edge.

And hipsters gonna hip

 

[Gradine]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 13
Icewind Dale 11
Neverwinter Nights 14 If it aint Infinity engine or dungeon crawler, GTFO
Neverwinter Nights II 20
Planescape: Torment 10 Clearly the best game on this list, even though I can see the logic that it's off-brand

 

[Prakriti]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 13
Icewind Dale 11
Neverwinter Nights 14
Neverwinter Nights II 18
Planescape: Torment 11

 

[Tyler Do'Urden]

No, I vote it down because I think the best D&D game should actually be part of the genre that D&D is iconic for: high fantasy, and at least have most of the same features and feel between the actual TTRPG, and the video game that represents it. It has nothing to do with me just trying to be edgy.

I agree with your logic.

I'd be upvoting Torment... but there's still one game on this list I like better.

To me, BG II *is* the greatest D&D ccrpg. Torment is a close second... but BG II edges it out in a number of ways.

 

[Yardiff]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 13+1=14
Icewind Dale 11
Neverwinter Nights 14
Neverwinter Nights II 18
Planescape: Torment 11-2=9

 

[Raunalyn]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 14
Icewind Dale 11-2 = 9
Neverwinter Nights 14
Neverwinter Nights II 18
Planescape: Torment 9+1 = 10

 

[Ed Laprade]

Baldur's Gate 29
Baldur's Gate II 25
Eye of the Beholder Series 14
Icewind Dale 9
Neverwinter Nights 14 +1 = 15
Neverwinter Nights II 18
Planescape: Torment 10 -2 = 8