D&D 5E SURVIVOR Supplement Edition--Volo's Guide Wins!

[Harzel]

Shady Dragon Inn (B/X)-- 1
Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--18
Creative Campaigning (2e)--16
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--18
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 8
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--19

 

[Wiseblood]

Shady Dragon Inn (B/X)-- 1-2=0
Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--18
Creative Campaigning (2e)--16+1=17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--18
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 8
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--19

lot's of 2e still here. It is my preferred resource.

 

[CleverNickName]

My favorite supplement of all time was AC9, Creature Catalogue, and my second-favorite was AC10, Bestiary of Giants and Dragons. Neither of them made the list for some reason (grumble grumble), so I was upvoting the only BECM supplement that did (Shady Dragon Inn, somehow). Now it's gone, so there's really nothing left for me to upvote on purpose. Guess I'll roll a d4...

And I'm downvoting VGtM for its price tag alone.

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--18
Creative Campaigning (2e)--16+1=17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--18+1=19 Rolled a 3.
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 8
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--19-2=17 Fifty bucks? Seriously?

 

[akr71]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--16
Creative Campaigning (2e)--16+1=17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 8
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--18

 

[Maxperson]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--17 - I used this again just last night. No other older supplement gets as much use from me.
Creative Campaigning (2e)--17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 6
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--18

 

[rczarnec]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--17
Creative Campaigning (2e)--17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 4
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--19

 

[Swarmkeeper]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--17
Creative Campaigning (2e)--17
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 2
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--20

 

[Eltab]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--17 - 2 = 15 Gotta put a downvote somewhere. "It's just business, nothing personal."
Creative Campaigning (2e)--17 + 1 = 18 Campaigning is supposed to be creative anyways, isn't it?
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 4
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--19

 

[JonnyP71]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--15
Creative Campaigning (2e)--19 A beautiful diamond in the 2E rough....
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 2
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--18 A fine necklace, sadly blighted by some flawed stones..


Edit - fixed the cross posts above...

 

[Sacrosanct]

Encyclopedia Magica (2e)--15
Creative Campaigning (2e)--20
Campaign Sourcebook and Catacomb Guide (2e)--19
Complete Guide to Villains (2e)-- 0
Volo's Guide to Monsters (5e)--18