Tell me, have you seen the Eberron CSB?

What do you think of Eberron now that you have taken a better look at it?

  • I love it! Whether it was worth the wait or I am totally suprised or whatever, this book rocks on t

    Votes: 52 37.1%
  • It's good! Enjoyable, worth my time and all that.

    Votes: 48 34.3%
  • Doesn't do a whole lot for me, but not a complete loss.

    Votes: 15 10.7%
  • Mother always said, if you can't say anything nice...

    Votes: 12 8.6%
  • But she wasn't always right. This thing is a waste.

    Votes: 13 9.3%

  • Poll closed .

Stone Dog

Adventurer
Alrighty then! The book is finally out and the opinions are flying.

A while ago I posted a poll asking ENworld readers how interested they were in the setting and now that the book is out I wonder, how have opinions changed?

I had a good sit down with the thing today at a Borders and I tell you it is just what I wanted it to be.

This is a simple 1-5 scale with a bit of flavor thrown into the options. For pyramid readers, yes I stole the format. ;)

Thanks for voting!
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

Going borderline here, between I love it and it's good - I've been sitting on the fence for a while, waitin' to see if it was any good, turns out it was definetly better than good. They did example characters the right way (in the Classes section, anyways - PrC section just had mechanical examples, but the examples they made of the base classes were nothing but flavor, just the way I like an example). The magic items were very cool (Quori designed dragon shard implants for psionic characters? Sign me up for a Kalashtar Fist of Errrr.... (Let's just call it a Psychic Fist, instead, given Zuken's lack of, yaknow, existance), with Ectoplasmic Fist Quori shards implanted along the backs of my hands.

The amount of detail that seems to have gone into the basics of the setting, too, really makes me happy - the 'common magic' is helped along by the fact that there are lots (in general, not relative, terms) of low level characters with the ability to create magical effects, be it adepts, magewrights or people with a dragonmark, all contribute to the ability to make use of magic on a wide-spread, if low, level. The economy seems to have been given alot of thought as well - the peasents and surf-type commoners seem to have been brought up in the world somewhat, being expected to have somewhere in the area of 50 pieces of silver at any given time (their life savings), while the other 40% of the population is dealing a few hundred in gold - justifying the prices in the PHB and the setting book somewhat.

Of course, one of the biggest things I've seen had to be the fantastic plot devices: Specifically the Eldritch Machines. Artifacts that basicly function as limited use wish spells - want commoner 1 to have his own army of damned souls? Perhaps he came across a (to make up names), Death Engine, an Eldritch Machine create by his towns insane founder, and kept a secret by the town counciler as a sort of a last resort - the fact that it never saw use during the Last War meant that it's lain there, most likely forgotten by now (assuming the council change members a few times in the past 102 years), until discovered.... and now insert Night of the Living Dead theme of choice and start. Or something like that, anyways.

In the end, I'm sure that you knew all this stuff, Stone Dog, being one of the biggest supportters, evanglists, guy-who-talks-a-heck-of-alot-about-it-and-seems-to-know-everything of this setting, but what the heck. Reccently, I've just felt the need to splat out all my thoughts on my latest purchases on the internet for some reason.
 

It's a really good book and I'll try to get someone else to DM, so I can finally play again.

btw, when stealing from Pyramid, could you also steal the "Other" option? There's always some people who don't fit into neat categories. ;)
 


Well, I wasn't exactly a naysayer, but while searching for a b-day* present for me sister* (which of course was fruitless), I saw the book sitting on the shelf in the bookstore and decided to take a look at it. After a few minutes, I decided to pick it up (as I had the cash on me, otherwise I probly* wouldn't have bought it). So basically I say it's a good book and worth the buy, quite enjoyable, I especially like the comic book page intros.

*All spelling and grammar errors are on purpose (I normally speak like this)
 

derelictjay said:
Well, I wasn't exactly a naysayer, but while searching for a b-day* present for me sister* (which of course was fruitless), I saw the book sitting on the shelf in the bookstore and decided to take a look at it. After a few minutes, I decided to pick it up (as I had the cash on me, otherwise I probly* wouldn't have bought it). So basically I say it's a good book and worth the buy, quite enjoyable, I especially like the comic book page intros.

*All spelling and grammar errors are on purpose (I normally speak like this)

I hate to break it to you, but the correct misspelling of sister is 'sistah.' You've spelled it correctly. Might want to edit that.
 


I picked it up the first day it became available. LOVE IT!
If I had to complain about one thing, it's be the fact that I now have about 50 adventure ideas in my head and I have to pick one.

The book is a gold mine I tell you.
 

I finally finished reading the thing yesterday and I was seriously impressed by it. Aside from how vividly the world was described the artwork was beautiful, and I'd be hard pressed to show you any unneeded white space. This is also one of the few campaign settings I've ever seen that can be used "right from the box" they go into enough detail on the world where I might feel confident playing/running a game.

While I certainly won't be building the book a shrine until I do get a chance to play it and figure out the ins and outs of the setting, I did feel compelled to give the book a favorable vote.
 
Last edited:


Remove ads

Top