Dunamin
First Post
[sblock=I guess that’s my judge cue]
* Drops silently down from ceiling and lands in split *
My interpretation of the Rules as Written support Halford. The critical hit rules state that you don’t max rolled extra damage that is activated by scoring a crit (such as by magic weapon enhancement). However, the extra damage from Sneak Attack is unrelated from whether or not you crit – its activation is tied to hitting with combat advantage, an entirely different requirement. To me, this implies that Sneak Attack damage is indeed maxed upon critting.
* Throws smokebomb and backflips into shadows *[/sblock]
* Drops silently down from ceiling and lands in split *
My interpretation of the Rules as Written support Halford. The critical hit rules state that you don’t max rolled extra damage that is activated by scoring a crit (such as by magic weapon enhancement). However, the extra damage from Sneak Attack is unrelated from whether or not you crit – its activation is tied to hitting with combat advantage, an entirely different requirement. To me, this implies that Sneak Attack damage is indeed maxed upon critting.
* Throws smokebomb and backflips into shadows *[/sblock]