Anniston meets the gaze of the Captain directly.
"Captain, with your indulgance, the charge that we have been present for every weirding is not entirely true. We were not present when the beast-man effected his transformation and we were not on the deck of this ship when the sailor was killed. It was only as a result of this unusual death that we became involved in these events."
"Second, a woman was killed in the lower hold. We believe this death was a necessary component of the summoning. The woman was killed when all of our party was in the room upstairs. We only discovered the body of the woman and hence the summoned demon as a result of hearing the scream."
"Third, just before our appointment here, we found traces of a magical blue powder on the faces of the men in the cabin. This powder appeared on the faces of the men after we left to investigate the screams from below decks. Your own officers were in the room guarding the prisoners. We do not know how the blue powder came to be on the faces of the prisoners. Perhaps the members of the crew that were present can help you to understand how the powder came to be on their faces."
"Finnally, if we did not discover and fight against the evil that was done here tonight; if our intentions were truely to perpetrate evil on this ship, then where are the members of your crew that claim to have defeated this evil? Which passengers have come forward to claim that they have themselves defeated the evil that you suspect us of having conjured?"
"Captain, if you suspect us of performing acts of great magic and evil that threatened your ship, then how do you explain that our criminal plans were not successful? If not us, then who is the hero that has saved the ship? If Jaroth was indeed attempting to smash the ship with his arcane power, then by what miracle has she been saved from certain destruction?"
"We have told you what happened and we have told you the truth. You may believe that we have saved this ship and every soul in it, or you may believe that we are the ones responsible for this great evil."
"We are prepared to answer any questions you may have for us."