Re: GENDER RANT FROM A LINGUIST!!!!!
DreamChaser said:
[rant]
Mage is not a gender specific word so the word "magistress" is just silly and implies that mages are inherently men, thus supporting the ancient men are better shtick that most of the educated people in the word are trying to get rid of.
The same is true of
actor (even many award shows have gotten rid of actress)
Name one. The truth is, the award show is the only place where the term actress is still regularly used.
I think you get the idea. Our historically sexist ideas make us think that the default must be male so we need another word to identify the female. We come up with these words thinking we're being enlightened but we aren't. We are just perpetuating the whole problem by refusing to change the core assumption.
[/rant]
DC
My turn
[rant]
And now for an extremely blunt and honest statement:
Take your Politically Correct rant and shove it were the sun don't shine!
And don't use "we."
YOU might have sexist ideas that motivates
YOUR use of the gender specific pronouns, but that doesn't mean that I or anyone else does. Speak only for
YOURSELF and do not insult my intelligence by pretending to know the motivation and intent behind my word choices.
I personally hate the improper use of the plural first and third person pronouns in an attempt to split people up into idealogical camps.
YOU can only speak for yourself, therefore use only the pronoun
I and do not attempt to speak for anyone else on this or any other issue.
I use the feminine form "sorceress" and I have coined others in my settings and in my made up languages not out of misogeny, but in recogninition of the fact that women can and do fill these roles. I want to make it clear that in addition to being the one of the most powerful sorcerers (male or female) in all the land, Telsindria is a woman. Name another setting that has a woman in the role of "most powerful caster / DM avatar." You won't quickly find one but you do find plenty of men in that role - Elminster, Merlin, Raistlin, Gandalf to quickly name four. I want it to be clear what and who Telsindria is. This also goes for my other characters.
That English grammar has the masuculine pronoun as a default is not something in my control. If this irks you, that's just too bad.
To sum up your rant, in the name of correcting this gross sexist insult to all women you would have us drop the mention of women from the structure of the language at all times and rob women of their gender identity. In order not to insult women you choose to hide them entirely.
That isn't any solution - that's a problem in it's own right.