The full pumpkin onslaught hasn't hit yet, but here was a new-to-me one in the store: The Left Hand Brewing Pumpkin Spice Latte Nitro. It was fine and I was torn between Solid Pumpkin Choice and Drinkable. I'm not usually a huge nitro fan, and it was too smooth too start. It had some extra spice at the end and the can finished well though, so I put it in the higher of those two categories (see full rankings from the past several years below).

The Sweet Baby Banana! by DuClaw was disappointing. Their Sweet Baby Jesus Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter is an all-star, and I like banana. I couldn't really taste the banana and it wasn't as good as the original without it. Will not be getting again.

My current pumpkin ratings, sorted by the beer advocate ratings (in parentheses) when available (updated 9 Oct 2023):
My Favorites (would order any time):
Cigar City Good Gourd (95/4.26)
Clown Shoes Gordo (91/4.14)
Southern Tier Warlock (89/3.99)
King Don's Pumpkin Ale by Catawba (86/3.83)
Big Muddy Brewing Pumpkin Smasher (84/3.73)
Thirsty Dog Pumpkin Ale (83/3.68)
Solid Pumpkin Choice:
Elysian Great Pumpkin (92/4.13)
Great Divide Pumpkin Spice Yeti (91/4.14)
Southern Tier Pumking (90/4.05)
Southern Tier Pumking Nitro (90/4.01)
Elysian Night Owl (88/3.95)
Rogue Pumpkin Patch Ale (87/3.85)
Sycamore Pumpkin Latte Blonde (87/3.83)
Voodoo Ranger Atomic Pumpkin by New Belgium (84/3.77)
Kentucky Pumpkin Barrel Ale (84/3.71)
Left Hand Brewing Pumpkin Spice Latte Nitro (83/3.60)
Sleepy Hollow Pumpkin Ale by Smokey Mountain Brewery (-/3.66)
Sugar Creek Pumpkin Blaster (-/-)
Drinkable:
Elysian Dark O' The Moon (88/3.94)
Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale (87/3.89)
Captain Lawrence Autumn Blaze Pumpkin Fall Ale (82/3.6)
UFO Journey to Planet Pumpkin! (82/3.6)
World Court Pumpkin Spice by Legal Remedy (-/-)
Steel Hands Pumpkin Spice Ale (-/-)
Pass:
Elysian Punkuccino (92/4.14)
Southern Tier Caramel Pumpking (90/4.04)
Gordgeous by NoDa (88/3.94)
Dogfish Head Punkin Ale (88/3.92)
Samuel Adams Jack-O Pumpkin Ale (74/3.20)
Shipyard Pumpkinhead Ale (70/3.02)
No Rating (IPAs, Sours, and super Hi-Grav):
Kickin' Knowledge Milkshake Pumpkin by Barrier Brewing (91/4.17) <- was expecting a stout... I need to read cans better!
Avery Brewing Rumpkin (91/4.08) <- wow that's boozy
Pumpkin Kerfuffle by Prairie Artisan Ales (89/4.03) <- reminded me of a cider