• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Welcome to the Halmae (updated 2/27/07)

Fajitas said:
>sigh< This was the adventure in which I discovered that my players really, really, really don't like moral ambiguities. They want the good guys on one side and the bad guys on the other side, and a nice red line dividing them. Oh, and big neon signs indicating which group is which. Yeah, they like that.

Hey what's not to like?

The other factor at work here was that after years the end of our mission to contact the five archmages was so close we could smell it. We were on an archmage roll. And as rewarding as it had been, the last time we'd gotten sucked into a villager-helping side trek it had taken us a year and two levels to take care of it. Were any of these unpleasant (and might I add, ungrateful) people going to help us find Barnabus? I don't think so.
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

Part the One-Hundred Sixty-Sixth
In which: the party finally finds someone who seems glad for their involvement.

“What was that?” Lt. Katib demands of Reyu once they are back in daylight again.

“A desert dialect,” Reyu offers. “Perhaps your translator is unfamiliar with it.”

“Ehkt’s left testicle it was. And what was that part about you living with the elves? I thought you were disinterested parties here.”

“I have spent time with the elves south of the Halmae. Not the Shesher. I promise, we are not spies.” Eventually, Reyu’s explanations and Anvil’s assurances convince Katib that the party members have not come with covert purposes. Also, he is soon distracted.

An old man hurries up. He is dressed like a soldier, but one long out of practice. His armor barely fits anymore, and his sword is badly tarnished. The man does not salute, nor even present himself to the Lieutenant. Instead, he is entirely focused on the party.

“Have you come to stop the elves?” he asks.

“Corporal—” Katib begins, but the other man talks right over him.

“Please, you’ve got to help us. We are innocents here. We have women and children. We don’t deserve to be living under siege. We’ll all be killed if you can’t hold the walls.”

“Corporal!” Katib’s tone causes even Reyu to unconsciously stiffen to attention. The soldier stops talking, realizing how far he has overstepped his bounds.

“I’m sorry, Lieutenant,” he says, “but this village has been my home for longer than I was a Corporal. I know it’s not the same for you, but this place means a lot more to me now than orders.”

Lt. Katib responds coldly. “Was there something you came here to inform me of, or are you merely harassing our guests?”

The man responds equally coldly. “The medics sent me to fetch you sir. The sergeant has taken a turn for the worse.” He looks beseechingly once more at the party. “I didn’t mean to bother you. Just… this village is my home.”

“We will certainly do what we can,” Reyu tells him.

(See? Once someone asks us to help, we’ve entirely willing.)

Lt. Katib addresses the other man sharply. “Tell the medics I’ll be there shortly. Dismissed.”

The man takes to his heels. Lt. Katib looks to Anvil. “Justicar, you mentioned you could provide healing?”

Anvil does not waste time repeating himself. “Where is this sergeant?”

“I’ll show you.”

###

While Anvil sees to Katib’s men, the rest of the party gathers to see if they have learned anything that will help them bring this situation to a peaceful resolution.

Jamaladeen’s whip has been produced for their inspection, and Lira excuses herself so that she can cast read magic unobserved by the Ebisites. She returns a few moments later and confirms Reyu’s hunch.

“Two of the strands are definitely the elven equivalent of scrolls of cure light wounds. The Shesher were telling us the truth. They did leave behind healing, they just didn’t leave that much.”

“It wouldn’t restore the ear though,” Eva clarifies.

“No,” Reyu allows, “but it would have healed the wound left behind.”

“Except that they’d be short an ear.”

“Well, yes.”

“What about the other cords?” Thatch asks.

“They’re knotted to look like scrolls, but whoever did it was just copying the other two strands, there’s no magic in them.”

Thatch rolls his eyes, “Flogged with healing? What’s that got to be like? ‘Ow!... Oh, that’s better.’”

Annika is either not amused, or doesn’t get that Thatch was trying to be funny. “Probably more like just, ‘Ow!’”

Thatch lets it go. “Elves, they’re all nuts.” He looks over at Reyu and ducks his head, just a little bit. “Present company excluded.”

Reyu cannot help but admit that Thatch might not be completely wrong, at least, not as far as Zili is concerned. “Never have I met someone so… determined to be martyred.”

“Is there any chance we can convince Jamaladeen to change his mind?” Kiara asks.

“You met him, what do you think?”

“Okay, probably not.”

“Lieutenant Katib doesn’t seem thrilled with the situation,” Lira points out. “Unfortunately, I think his hands are tied.”

“He said he had to bring the children to Nyarii to stand trial,” Kiara recalls. “Couldn’t Anvil make a ruling right here? That would at least settle things.”

“Anvil isn’t an Ebisite Justicar though,” Annika reminds her.

Eva suddenly claps her hands. “Wait a second, there’s huge reinforcement of soldiers three days away, right? I bet they’ll have an Ebisite Justicar with them.”

There is a brief silence.

“Umm,” Thatch finally says, “I think that’s the first not-crazy plan I’ve heard in days.”

###

Although Lieutenant Katib has no problem with having this matter settled here instead of Nyarii, he is dubious that the elves will be agreeable.

“I can’t authorize anything unless I have assurances from the elves they will accept the ruling. But I’m willing to negotiate in good faith if they are.”

Reyu and the rest of the party go back to the elves under cover of a while flag to explain the human side of the situation. As expected, the War Hand is not any more sympathetic, but she does agree to meet with the humans if there is someone who can negotiate the return of the children. As a gesture of good faith, she promises that the elves will not attack the village that night.

The party quickly sends back word to Lt. Katib, and with another exchange of messages, a meeting is set for the next morning.

###

The chosen spot for the negotiations is in the middle of the burned-out buffer zone between the wild scrub and the earthworks surrounding the village.

The party goes ahead to arrive at the designated sport first. The Ebisites are next. Lieutenant Katib waits nervously, as though expecting an ambush at any time. He only relaxes fractionally when the elves appear—much closer than Eva would have thought possible with the limited cover available—and join them.

The War Hand and her retinue arrive wearing full war-paint and armor. Not to be outdone, Lt. Katib and his men are in full battle-dress as well.

Lira, having been nominated as the most diplomatic and bilingual of the group, looks from one side to the other. Yup, this is going to be interesting.
 

Part the One-Hundred Sixty-Seventh
In which: someone gets something cut-off… but it’s not who or what you think.

The talks are long and difficult. Lira experiments with keeping both sides together to discuss their disagreements… then with giving them time and space to cool-off as she and Eva go back and forth between them, trying to nail down areas for compromise and concession.

After several hours she isn’t positive she wouldn’t rather they just start attacking each other and be done with it. However, they do eventually work out the beginnings of a compromise.

The War Hand is loathe to give up her advantage of numbers by allowing the Ebisite Justicar time to arrive. However, she is willing to wait for him, provided that the Justicar comes alone, unaccompanied by the rest of the Ebisite column. Unfortunately, she will make no promises that the elves will not retaliate if they are not pleased with the Justicar’s decision.

Lt. Katib would obviously like more in the way of assurances, but—with the proviso of safe-passage from the elves—agrees to send a fast rider requesting the military Justicar to leave the rest of the retinue behind on the road in hopes of negotiating a settlement.

In return, the War Hand pledges that the elves will not attack the village. At least, not until she hears the Justicar’s ruling.

With that hammered out, Lira tries to push for an additional concession from the Elves by floating the possibility of allowing civilian residents of the village to depart under amnesty, leaving only the soldiers trapped by the siege.

This is quickly shot-down by the War Hand and her aides, who insist that anyone leaving the village under any circumstances that do not include the return of their children is unacceptable.

Lira steps aside from the two parties for a moment to confer with Eva… and try to reign in her frustration.

“So, it’s a non-starter” she spits, “apparently their Elven honor demands the murder of innocent civilians.”

Lira is naturally conversing with Eva in Common, and had assumed that she was far enough away that the elves, with their seemingly rudimentary grasp of the language, would not understand her.

Then both women realize that the Elven delegation has gone abruptly silent.

“Oh crap.”

(Note: with her charisma, skill points, and +2 from Eva’s assist, Lira had +18 to that diplomacy roll. Her grand total: 19. “Crap” was the nicest thing I said when that die came up.)

###

Lira tries to apologize for her choice of words, which she readily admits were unthinking and unfortunate, but the War Hand is having none of it.

“You have insulted my honor, and I demand satisfaction.”

Lira, who has spent most of the day trying to be polite to people who seem to have no interest in avoiding a big fight where they will get to pound each other’s skulls in, finally looses what remains of her patience. “Well what would make you happy?” she asks sarcastically. “My ear?”

The War Hand almost smiles, but not in any way that could be construed as friendly. “Not necessarily. The small finger off of your right hand would also be acceptable.”

The party makes clear that this is not exactly an acceptable compromise.

Their protests are matched by several Elves who come forward as though to take their restitution right then, when suddenly Reyu steps in front of the young sorcerer.

“This human is under my protection.”

The War Hand is unruffled. “Then we will take your ear instead.”

Lira speaks up. “Reyu, this is crazy—”

Reyu doesn’t even spare her a glance. “Be quiet, youngling. This no longer concerns you.”

Lira shuts up.

Reyu addresses the War Hand. “She is a baby. She does not know your ways, and meant no offense.”

“Meant or not, offense was given.”

“Why not take her braids?”

The War Hand gives a disdainful snort. “Her braids mean nothing.” However, the suggestion has given her pause. “Would you offer yours in her stead?”

A long, pregnant silence.

“You cannot have my name braid. But yes, if you will agree to wait until the human Justicar has arrived and made his ruling in this matter, I will offer my achievement braid.”

“We will consider it.”

As the War Hand turns to confer with her people, and the Ebisites try to figure out what has just happened, Lira taps Reyu on the shoulder. “You don’t have to do this.”

Reyu smiles a touch ironically. “It would seem that I do. Unless you have something else to offer, aside from your ears and fingers.”

Lira checks carefully to make sure that no one can overhear, then says, “Do you think they’d be interested in my name?”

Reyu frowns. “You would no longer be Lira?”

The sorcerer shifts from foot to foot and pulls on one ear unconsciously. “No. I mean, that’s what I go by, with you guys, but it’s not my… uh… real name.”

Reyu blinks rapidly a few times. “What is your—?”

“Giovanna Niccolira Pauletta Rufina Pulcer Marie Allessandra di Vittani, and if that was your name you wouldn’t use it all either.”

Reyu is forced to see the point. “Does it have meaning in your culture?”

Lira snorts. “It means: the short, red-haired, pretty daughter of Niccolo and Allessandra di Vittani, with a strong connotation of ‘she is healthy, and will bear you many children.’”

Reyu sighs. “I do not know that the Shesher would value the gift of a name you do not use. And they would undoubtedly give you a new name so that all elves would know of your dishonor.”

“I didn’t mean to offend them.”

Reyu sighs again. “I know.”

###

The War Hand returns to address Reyu after only a few moments deliberation. “We will accept your achievement braid in return for your human’s offense,” she informs her.

Something in the War Hand’s tone kills the last of Reyu’s goodwill towards her desert sisters. “Fine,” she spits back, “and let me be clear. You have my braid, but that is all you have. If this comes to bloodshed, I will not lend my bow to your cause.”

The War Hand doesn’t seem particularly worried by the loss. “Understood.”

And with that, Reyu lifts her dagger, and takes off her hat.

Of course, Reyu’s hat is actually Lira’s hat, which is actually a hat of disguise, and so the moment she removes it, she also removes the illusion making her appear human.

This comes as a bit of a shock to the assembled Ebisites.

So while Anvil reassures Lt. Katib that there is no treachery abroad, and Katib convinces his men to stand down, Reyu takes out a short dagger, lifts the beaded braid detailing all of her achievements since she became an adult in the eyes of her people, and slices it off, clean to the scalp.

The War Hand watches, impassive. Reyu holds up the braid, just above the War Hand’s outstretched palm. “We have an agreement?”

The War Hand nods, and Reyu gives her the severed lock of hair.
 

And this is why "I take 10." are my absolute favourite words as a PC :)

Though given that you got a 19 anyway, the elves' response seems a little excessive, unless you're playing with a '1s are automatic failures' house rule. Assuming the elves were unfriendly, a 19 should shift them up to indifferent, not make them more unfriendly.

Obviously, Fajitas is just evil :)
 


Hostile to the Ebisites, sure. Hostile to the PCs? Doesn't make sense. Would you allow someone to whom you were Hostile to enter an enemy encampment under some claim of trying to free your children? Would you trust someone to whom you were Hostile to broker an agreement between you and your enemy? The elven behaviour toward the PCs has thus far been Unfriendly, not Hostile.

Of course, were I at the table when this would have happened, my reaction would have been "We're trying to help you save your children and now you want to mutilate one of my companions because your feelings are hurt? See you on the battlefield, lady."
 

Capellan said:
Of course, were I at the table when this would have happened, my reaction would have been "We're trying to help you save your children and now you want to mutilate one of my companions because your feelings are hurt? See you on the battlefield, lady."

Same here. My response would have been something like "What, you think we're doing this because we agree with you? We're doing it to protect the innocents, and if we're on anyone's side, it's not yours." Anvil and Reyu have both said things along these lines. I'm sort of amazed that the PCs went along with this, actually; do the Elves honestly believe the players agree with them at all? Have the players given any indication that they value the "honor" of these Elves?
Of course, I tend to play the sort of characters who'd just write the whole thing off and walk away at this point. I mean sure, you know they'll storm the village and try to kill everyone before the army arrives, but then they'll be wiped out in return, and they know it. If that sort of enlightened self-interest isn't enough to keep them at the negotiations in spite of a few insults, what can you do?

In other words, you've done a beautiful job making a morally ambiguous crisis for the players to get stuck in. Bravo!
 

I think I'm there with you on being ready to just leave or even throw in with the villagers in this case. Of course, a duel to first blood would also have been a fairly "traditional" way to settle the matter, but that might not work for the Shesher culture.
 

Ahh, but what many of you don't realize is just how racist Reyu is. Until she lost her achievement braid she would have fought with the elves. Even with the arrogant behavior of the war hand, she would *never* fight against them.

And again -- innocents. Elven children who don't really deserve slavery. Human families who don't deserve slaughter. So it would have taken more rudeness than we faced to make her walk away.

Not that the rest of the party agreed, mind you.

-WLS
 

Maybe it's just me, but I don't see a moral crisis here. The elves are clearly in the wrong. Their children mutilated a group of humans, left insufficient healing in an unrecognizable form, and are making war on a human village that only has a loose connection with the soldiers who are trying to make right. Slavery, by terms of a world such as this, is probably a valid form of punishment for that type of crime, whetehr you agree with it or not by modern moral standards.

As a player, I wouldn't have tried to negotiate at all. I would have immediately stood with the soldiers and drawn sword.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top