D&D General What do you say when someone is thinking of quitting your game?

Possible there is something else going on. If he has a new significant other, that person may want more then one Sunday a month. Stress leading to addiction issues can cause a reassessment of life activities(one of our long time players is dealing with this and has stepped away from in person gaming). If work has become more demanding, there may not be enough hours in his week to do everything that needs doing.

Might consider making one of those Sundays a board game session. Give everyone a break from the old regular. Make sure your departed friend knows he is welcome to attend.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

“Thanks for the head’s up. I’ve had a lot of fun with you at the table so I hate to see you go. If there’s anything I can do to make things more fun or engaging for you let me know. There will always be a seat at the table for you.”

The reasoning might involve a lot of stuff outside the game, so, as others have mentioned, it’s probably best to leave that alone for the time being.

Consider making a point of hanging out in the next little while and consider a bit of a going away bash with the group.
Yeah I think that's about all you can say without knowing why they're quitting on a deeper level.

My personal experience is that things don't generally just "stop being fun", there are usually more specific reasons, even if they're not directly connected to the game. Pretty much everyone (touch wood) who has left my main group did so because they moved away physically, and at least two of them rejoin whenever they're in proximity!

But I do have a lot of experience of people stopping playing long-term multiplayer videogames. The main ones I can think of:

1) Overwork and obsessing about work and work being stressful kind of a destroyed a friend's ability to appreciate really any kind of "casual" or "fun" leisure activity. He recovered it eventually, but it took a long-ass time.

2) More positively, a good friend transitioned and she found that she was just no longer as excited by MMOs, and much more interested in physical fitness in a serious way (something she'd had little interest in before). I think, if I'm doing armchair psychology, maybe being a woman IRL meant there was less/no thrill to being one in a videogame, and with the right body, exercise felt more fun, but whatever the cause, it was good, even I've seen a lot less of her since (we're in different countries), because she seems hugely happier now.

3) Most ridiculous one - a guildie rather than a real friend, but I knew him a long time, declared games "weren't fun anymore" (echoing the OP's friend slightly, but maybe that's just the edit), and that he was done with them. We later learned this was because he'd got a new GF, of a somewhat stereotypically snobbish-ly opinionated nature, who took the view that all games were for children/teenagers, so it was her or games. When that inevitably blew up (because really, come on!), a few months later, he was back.

But unless the person is a close friend anyway, they're not likely to want to discuss the deeper reasons (except maybe if they come back). If you're aware of them, then you may have an idea if/when the person is likely to be interested in playing again.

I still think that it can't hurt to ask why. It just might be burnout on d&d. 6 years of 3 games a month is lots of gaming in one specific system and more or less same type of game ( no matter how you spin it, 5e is high powered high fantasy).
That is the one thing that might be worth asking about, I think. But the issue is that they might simply not know, they might just know they're not enjoying this - this is why I think it's helpful, even when you have a long-running campaign, to drop in the odd one-shot in another (easy to learn) system. You can gauge system burnout pretty well from that - like, if you have a player (or players) who are suddenly way more engaged, and then you know they may well be a burned out on the main game, and maybe that's worth thinking about.
 

I'd echo the boardgame alternative.
We have this option where one of the core (when it's their turn) gets to invite an outsider to the boardgame session. That way the group networks and expands by meeting friends of friends and there is always a fresh face present.

And when you're playing those board or card games that require 7+ players you have a decent pool of players to select from.
 

Wish him the best and let him know there is always a chair for him at your table.
Pretty much this. If there happens to be something specific that can be done to avoid the departure, then we'll talk, of course. But in my experience (at least recently), it's been things like pressure of time, or simply a mismatch in tastes, or something like that - in which case, the best thing has been to part amicably.
 

I just got a private message from a friend and gamer at my table that he's stepping away from our D&D/RPGs. It makes me sad to hear. I've been DMing for a long time, and I've seen it happen. I've burned out for periods of time. I'd like to think I run great games, but I also realize not everyone can or will play D&D for decades. But I want to say something to him to (1) find out if I'm part of the problem, (2) see if he just needs a break (or is there more going on), and (3) keep friends no matter what.

Background: in 2019 I moved states and randomly met some folks of similar age for a D&D game, maybe to start a group. Only one had ever played D&D before, and only a little. We all clicked and have been routinely meeting about 3 Sundays a month at my house. Fast forward nearly 6 years. We've just finished an 18-month campaign and are starting a new one. Out of the blue after our first campaign session (I had no clue he was unhappy with it all), I get a message (shortened for content):

There’s no easy way to write this but I need to step away from the table and dnd. It's been building for a while and taken me a long time to come to terms with but I'm not having fun anymore. The game just doesn’t hold my attention like it used to and that’s on me. Obviously there’s a lot I could share regarding how I came to this decision, and I’m happy to do so at some point. To be clear, nothing but the best of thoughts for you all. I’m gonna miss hanging out and playing with everybody so much but this is a change I need to make....Thanks so much for the years of fun. All that said, I don’t know how best to do this. I’m happy to play another session (or a couple) and share all this firsthand but wanted you have final say on how best for me to say goodbye to the group.
1. thank you for your message.
2. I hope it is just a break of a few months. Or are we going find you ran over Jasper with his car.
3. i will keep a chair open for you. And see you at some of non game activities.
note if you are only friends who just play d&d together, I don't think friends is the right word to describe this person. LBut I am a programmer and i like my categories defined.
 

I feel that the player did a good job of communicating with you. Thumbs up for that.

They had mentioned no longer having fun with playing the game but had also mentioned that they would miss spending time and hanging out with the group. As others have said, they may simply be burned out on D&D. Perhaps they would be more interested in other activities or maybe even different game systems.
 


Remove ads

Top