What is the "Best. Ravenloft module. Ever?"

[Plane Sailing]

I'd recommend which ever adventure is *least* like the abysmal mind-flayer based adventure which was awful, awful, awful. At best the PC's are placed against foes which would annihilate them, at worst they just stand around and watch a deus ex machina solve the plot for them.

That was the worst, most unusable adventure I've ever seen.

Which means the inverse of it must be pretty good

 

[Assenpfeffer]

I6.

Though quite a few of the 2E Ravenloft modules were pretty good. Generally, I thought they were the best adventures TSR was doing at that time.

 

[DaveMage]

My players enjoyed "Feast of Goblyns". Pretty easy to run too.

 

[JeffB]

Barring the original , I really liked Carnival, though I don't have a ton of experience w/RL.

 

[Angelsboi]

Hour of the Knife if you like mysteries and cool Jack the Ripper stuff

 

[diaglo]

I6 Ravenloft.

there is no substitute.

lost my favorite character there.

 

[reveal]

Thanx for all the advice so far!

How about modules for geared towards characters of level 3 or 4? Also, how hard is it to scale down the modules mentioned above?

 

[Piratecat]

I'd recommend which ever adventure is *least* like the abysmal mind-flayer based adventure which was awful, awful, awful.

I knew I liked and respected you for a reason.

I concur; let it be known that if anyone says that their favorite Ravenloft module is "Thoughts of Darkness," I'm officially banning their ass from the boards in fear that they'll accidentally pollute others!

 

[Davelozzi]

Thoughts of Darkness.

 

[Drunken Master]

i have zero ravenloft experience except for this:
i was gonna run a ravenloft adventure where the villain was a rakshasa, and it seemed really cool (i've always dug rakshasas), but we never got around to playing it. it had a nifty india/jungle thing going on. if my old 2e stuff wasn't in my parents' basement 3000 miles away, i'd convert it and run it now.