Grognard-in-denial here (53). I'm lukewarm on them. When they're "scripty" or "acted" (like Critical Role, an obviously well-produced show I just don't enjoy), it feels more like theater than play (and sometimes bad theater, and I won't name names here). When they're turn-the-camera-on-while-we-play, it feels more like I stumbled into someone's basement, and I'm "the new guy," not in on their jokes or interpersonal history. There's a sweet spot in the middle, and then it becomes more a question of whether I like the game they're running, and how it's run. Let's say it comes down to, "Would I want to be at that table?" I'm fussy, but I do enjoy a subset here and there. And sometimes I learn something; and I have a LOT of room for improvement as both a DM and player.